Salt Lake City/ Politics & Govt

Ivins Man Fights $50 Honking Ticket From St. George ‘No Kings’ Rally

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 16, 2026
Ivins Man Fights $50 Honking Ticket From St. George ‘No Kings’ RallyVernon Worthen Park — Site of No Kings Rally
Google Street View

A $50 ticket for honking a car horn is turning into a courtroom fight over free speech in southern Utah. Jack Hoopes, a retired attorney from Ivins, was cited for “unlawful horn use” after he honked in support of demonstrators at a March 28 “No Kings” protest at Vernon Worthen Park in St. George, and he's refusing to simply pay the fine and move on.

Hoopes says he honked along with other motorists while driving home past the demonstration on 400 East, and tapped his horn once more after spotting a friend, according to The Salt Lake Tribune. A police officer pulled him over, and Hoopes says the officer initially intended to let him off with a warning. That changed, he says, after he asked why another honking driver nearby had not been stopped. “But the way you are acting, I'm giving you a ticket now,” the officer reportedly told him, per the same account. Hoopes believes the officer cited him only after being questioned, and suspects the rally's political message played a role.

Hoopes, who served as a prosecutor in Fremont County, Idaho, in the 1980s, says he's ready to pay the $50 fine if he ultimately loses the case. But he's not interested in a quiet settlement. He says a friend who used to work as a deputy prosecutor expected the ticket would have been tossed out quickly, and he wants a court to settle a bigger question: whether his honks counted as political expression and whether the law was applied fairly.

A Disputed Street and a Contested Law

Utah law prohibits unreasonably loud or harsh horns and limits horn use on highways to safety warnings. Hoopes argues his horn was neither loud nor harsh and is challenging whether the statute should even apply to someone honking in support of protesters. Police told him he'd violated that code and said Flood Street — where the stop reportedly occurred — counts as a highway under the law, according to FOX 13 News. But FOX 13's own review of city, county and state records found Flood Street is not designated as a highway, and that there are no signs on the street identifying it as one.

St. George police have defended their handling of the protest overall, telling KJZZ that they issued citations to both protesters and counterprotesters that day, not just one side. Jordan Minnick, a captain with the St. George Police Department, said the department enforces laws based on the relevant statutes and lacks authority to simply dismiss citations once issued. Minnick declined to address whether ticketing drivers for honking at a political rally could infringe on First Amendment expression rights. St. George prosecutors are moving forward with the case against Hoopes.

Trial Set for Nov. 24

Hoopes' trial is scheduled for Nov. 24 in St. George Justice Court. He plans to call several witnesses and intends to question the officer directly about enforcement practices at other protests, hoping to show whether honking has been treated differently depending on a rally's cause. He also plans to ask the city to dismiss the charge and to enforce its ordinances consistently at peaceful demonstrations regardless of viewpoint. Hoopes says he will not drop the challenge, citing both selective-enforcement and free-speech concerns.

His wife, Lorna Hoopes, says the couple has attended several No Kings events and that honking in support of passing demonstrators is a standard show of solidarity nationwide — and not unique to left-leaning causes. She said the same horn-honking happens at conservative political rallies and community celebrations as well. She pointed to one example: the couple once watched protesters on a Park City freeway overpass ask motorists to honk in support of “medical freedom” after a concert, and she has questioned why officers in that instance didn't tell demonstrators they couldn't hold up signs asking drivers to honk.

A Growing Legal Debate Over Car-Horn Speech

The St. George rally that triggered Hoopes' ticket was sizable — the Los Angeles Times reported a crowd of roughly 1,500 marching through the park's main picnic area that day. Tom Ford, a staff attorney with the ACLU of Utah, argues that using a car horn to express a political viewpoint deserves the highest level of First Amendment protection. Ford said citing Hoopes leaves residents uncertain whether they can safely honk to express political beliefs, calling it the kind of governmental overstep that improperly stifles points of view and strikes at the core of the First Amendment.

Hoopes' case isn't unprecedented. In February 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review a challenge brought by Susan Porter, who was ticketed for honking in support of a 2017 rally outside her congressman's office in California, according to USA Today. The justices declined without comment, leaving California's horn law intact. A Ninth Circuit majority had reasoned that limiting the law to honks proven to distract drivers or disturb the peace would be too difficult, if not impossible, for officers to enforce. Similar horn-use laws are on the books in 41 states, according to court records cited in that report — meaning Hoopes' St. George fight could resonate well beyond southern Utah's city limits.