
A federal judge has ruled that a Chicago woman's lawsuit over her 2023 arrest for carrying a legally licensed firearm can proceed, finding her claims plausibly point to a broader pattern of Chicago police officers targeting Black drivers with valid gun licenses. Lucy Washington, a single mother of two and a real estate agent, was pulled over in December 2023 for failing to use her turn signal — and ended up in handcuffs despite holding a valid concealed-carry license.
According to the court opinion in Washington v. Chicago, the traffic stop and arrest occurred in Chicago on December 16, 2023. Washington told officers she owned a gun, had a concealed-carry license, and had the weapon in her car, and she even showed officers phone communications from the state confirming her license renewal, according to the lawsuit's allegations reported by CBS News Chicago. An officer told her the state database showed her concealed-carry license as expired, but police arrested her anyway despite her attempt to prove the renewal.
Washington had just renewed her license before the stop, according to CBS News Chicago's reporting, which also found that the Cook County State's Attorney's Office approved a felony charge of aggravated unlawful use of a weapon against her. Her felony charge was eventually dismissed, and she spent time and money on legal fees to get her case expunged, per the same outlet. Courts ultimately determined that her concealed-carry license was valid at the time of her arrest.
What the Court Opinion Says About Illinois Gun Law
The underlying court opinion lays out why Washington's license should have been recognized as valid despite what the database showed officers. Illinois law provides that a concealed-carry license remains valid even after its printed expiration date, provided that the licensee has submitted a renewal application and is otherwise eligible to possess a license, the opinion states. According to Washington's complaint, her renewal application was under review with the Illinois State Police Firearms Services Bureau at the time she was pulled over.
Washington sued the city of Chicago and the officers who arrested her, alleging false arrest, illegal search and seizure, and other counts, including a claim that the defendants violated her Second Amendment rights, per the CBS News Chicago report on the new ruling. Her lawsuit also brings a Monell claim, alleging the police department has a pattern and practice of similar stops and arrests targeting Black drivers who hold valid gun licenses. The city of Chicago attempted to have Washington's case dismissed entirely.
Judge Finds the Case No Longer Rests on One Incident
In a May 1, 2025, order, U.S. District Judge Virginia M. Kendall dismissed Washington's Monell claim without prejudice, while noting that Washington might still be able to build a plausible Monell claim, particularly with the aid of discovery on her other claims, according to the court opinion. Per the more recent ruling reported by CBS News Chicago, Kendall has now found that Washington's lawsuit plausibly alleges a widespread practice of discrimination against Black drivers with valid gun licenses, allowing the Monell claim and the broader case to move forward.
Kendall said Washington's allegations plausibly describe officers targeting Black drivers with firearms and then conducting unconstitutional seizures and arrests, the outlet reported. The judge also said Washington no longer relies solely on her own incident to support her claim. Washington's lawsuit names several other drivers arrested in similar situations, including two drivers featured in the CBS News Chicago investigation, and the case is still ongoing.
A Pattern CBS News Chicago Says It Found Before
CBS News Chicago investigators first reported on similar arrests of three Black gun owners with valid concealed-carry licenses in October 2025. That earlier investigation identified state Rep. Curtis Tarver, Louis McWilliams and Washington herself as people whose guns appeared in a police database, finding that all three had valid firearm licenses and that their cases were ultimately dismissed. Tarver has said an officer arrested him after a traffic stop even though the officer acknowledged his concealed-carry license was valid but told him it showed as revoked.
The station's reporting found several cases in which police stopped Black gun owners for minor traffic violations and then charged them with felonies, even though they held legal firearm licenses. Neither CPD nor the Cook County State's Attorney's Office tracks how often drivers with valid FOID and concealed-carry cards are wrongly charged, the outlet reported, leaving no official count of how widespread the problem might be.
Traffic Stop Data Shows Racial Disparities
The case lands against a backdrop of documented racial disparities in Chicago traffic enforcement. Illinois Department of Transportation data shows Black drivers are pulled over in Chicago at roughly four times the rate of white drivers, according to the lawsuit's allegations. A separate analysis by the Chicago Sun-Times found that, depending on the benchmark used, Black drivers were 3.6 or 5.6 times more likely than white drivers to be stopped by Chicago police in 2025, even as overall stops fell to 224,851 — down 23.3% from 2024 and 58.0% from 2023.
About 67.6% of those 2025 stops were for non-moving violations, the Sun-Times reported, and nearly 95% of Illinois law enforcement agencies that reported at least 50 stops had higher stop rates for Black drivers than white drivers. Washington has described the toll her own arrest took, saying in a past interview that her mugshot appearing online cost her clients as a realtor and that the wrongful arrest affected her mental health. She has also said she still feels trauma and paranoia when she sees or is followed by a police car.
Both the Chicago Police Department and the Chicago Law Department declined to comment, citing the pending litigation, according to CBS News Chicago. The outlet's investigation was reported by Dorothy Tucker, a CBS 2 Chicago reporter since 1984 and president of the National Association of Black Journalists, alongside investigative journalist and producer Samah Assad. With Kendall's ruling, Washington's federal lawsuit may now proceed against the city of Chicago and the officers who arrested her.









