Chicago/ Crime & Emergencies

Gary Man's 105-Year Sentence Upheld in Fatal Ambush of Neighbor at Willows Apartments

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Gary Man's 105-Year Sentence Upheld in Fatal Ambush of Neighbor at Willows ApartmentsSource: howtostartablogonline.net / Wikimedia Commons

The Indiana Court of Appeals has upheld Thomas Starks’ convictions in the fatal shooting of his neighbor outside the Willows apartments, leaving in place his 105-year prison sentence. Starks, a Gary man, had challenged evidence admitted at trial; the appellate panel concluded the trial judge did not abuse her discretion in admitting the evidence at issue.

Gary Police were called to the Willows apartments on the 300 block of Clark Road around 11 p.m. on Aug. 8, 2023, after a report of gunfire, according to the Chicago Tribune. A Lake County jury found Starks guilty of killing his neighbor, Kajah Wilson, and shooting her fiancé, who survived. Court records cited by The Times identify him as Richard Casson; a separate Yahoo News report gives his name as Richard Casson.

The case also involved a burglary at the victims’ apartment. The Tribune reported that surveillance footage showed Starks and his sister, Leticia Starks, entering the apartment. The alleged stolen property included inventory from Gasson’s shoe-resale business, a mobile phone and an iPad.

Sister's Testimony and a Burglary Caught on Camera

Leticia Starks testified that she had lied when she signed a May 2024 plea agreement implicating her brother in the burglary, according to Yahoo News. She was separately found guilty of burglary in that incident.

Starks argued on appeal that his sister’s trial testimony and Facebook Messenger records should not have been admitted. The records included statements he allegedly posted from his personal phone to a group called Hooliganism. The appeals court found that Lake Superior Judge Natalie Bokota did not abuse her discretion in admitting the challenged evidence, and that any presumed error involving other evidence was harmless.

Pathologist's Findings and Corroborating Evidence

Trial evidence included testimony from forensic pathologist Dr. Zhuo Wang, who determined Wilson had been shot seven times from above, according to Yahoo News. Appellate Judge Dana Kenworthy cited the burglary video and evidence that Starks pawned Casson’s phone on the day he stole it as corroborating evidence.

A July 25, 2023, police report described the victims’ apartment door handle as broken, as if someone had forced entry, the Tribune reported. The report preceded the Aug. 8 shooting.

Sentencing Details and What Comes Next

The Times reported that Leticia Starks pleaded guilty and served six months in jail with another 2½ years on probation; the Tribune reported a six-year split term for Thomas Starks on the burglary charge. The Indiana Department of Correction lists March 14, 2102, as Starks’ earliest possible release date.

Starks may ask the Indiana Supreme Court to review the Court of Appeals’ decision.

How an appeal could reach the Indiana Supreme Court

A request for the Indiana Supreme Court to review a Court of Appeals decision is made through a petition to transfer. Under Indiana Appellate Rule 57, the petition is due within 45 days of an adverse Court of Appeals decision if rehearing was not sought, or within 30 days after the court disposes of a rehearing petition if rehearing was sought.