
Giovanni's is marking 50 years in Beachwood, and the room is still built around a cart. Dover sole is deboned at the table, three desserts are finished in front of the guest, and maître d' Pierre Luigi Gregori has worked there the entire time.
The restaurant occupies an office building at 25550 Chagrin Blvd. in Beachwood, with lunch and dinner, a 100-seat dining room and a 75-seat patio. Cleveland.com reported Tuesday that owner Carl Quagliata still cooks elsewhere by day and works the Beachwood floor at night. He opened Giovanni's in 1976. With chef Zach Ladner, he now runs a small group of Cleveland-area kitchens around that original room.
From a Lost Lease in Mentor
Carl Quagliata did not arrive on Chagrin Boulevard as a first-time operator. He had run The White House in Mentor for nine years when he lost the lease, then opened Giovanni's. Cleveland Scene places that opening in 1976. He named the restaurant for an uncle who had recently died and put the dining room in an office building. He has said it was busy from the beginning.
The Mentor connection did not end with the lease. Cleveland.com reports that Giovanni's still draws third-generation customers and original customers who first visited the Mentor restaurant. A lost lease in one suburb became a 50-year dining room in another, and some of those original guests made the move. Third-generation customers are still in the count, beside people who ate at The White House. Cleveland Scene credits the same kitchen with launching the careers of Sergio Abramof and Michael Symon.
There was a brighter guest list, too. Giovanni's hosted Sammy Davis Jr., Bob Hope and Engelbert Humperdinck, and the Front Row Theater sat nearby. Quagliata has given Cleveland Magazine a plainer measure of the room he runs. "About 65% of our customers are return guests," he said.
Three Tables on a Busy Night
Quagliata has said service is the key to the restaurant's success, and the floor is staffed to match. On busy nights, servers are assigned three tabletops each. Three tables is a short section in a 100-seat dining room. It is also the time required to debone a Dover sole in front of the guest. Bananas foster, cherries jubilee and zabaglione are finished at the table, too. He has said Giovanni's was busy from the beginning, so the three-table rule is not a slow-night luxury.
Gregori has been the maître d' for all 50 years, Cleveland.com reported. Ladner has been in the kitchen 17, and he attributes the restaurant's longevity to Quagliata's dedication to good food, good service and daily presence. The owner still works the evening shift.
Zagat put a public number on that reputation in the middle of the run. On April 10, 2013, Cleveland.com reported that Zagat Survey had named Giovanni's among the top 120 restaurants in the country. In the Cleveland-area rankings, Giovanni's finished second for service, behind Chez Francois, and 10th for decor. The service placing is the one that still matches a floor assigned three tables at a time.
Sixteen Days and a Larger Bar
The room those servers work has been changed more than once. The anniversary coverage says Giovanni's has had four updates over five decades. The remodeling with dates, a closure and a measured result was reported in 2012 and 2013.
On June 12, 2012, the plans were still prospective. Cleveland.com reported that a small party room would be incorporated into the front of the restaurant and that the bar would be expanded. The shutdown, when it came, was measured in days, not a season. The April 10, 2013 account said Giovanni's had reopened about three months earlier after closing for 16 days. The bar was enlarged by 30 percent, a dining room was upgraded, and a small corporate dining room had been added.
Lunch and dinner both went dark for those 16 days. The June 2012 plan put a small party room at the front. The post-reopening account called the new space a small corporate dining room. A party room in the plan, a corporate room in the finished report: either description is a table that does not have to sit in the main dining room. Fifty years has room for a renovation that lasted 16 days. The Chagrin Boulevard address did not move with the bar.
Staples, Specials and 450 Bottles
Ladner has said the regular menu changes infrequently. Regulars are the constituency for that choice. Cleveland Scene has described the matching job as a balance between stability and variety. At Giovanni's, the specials carry the new dishes, and the standing menu is allowed to stay familiar.
The cooking runs Italian and fine-dining American. Beef bourguignon made with short rib tips sits on the American side of the menu. Halibut is the most popular dish. Dover sole is the one the room still performs. Popularity and the tableside show are not the same plate. The wine program, recognized by Wine Spectator, carries more than 450 selections. Set next to 100 seats inside and 75 on the patio, that list is a deep cellar for the number of chairs.
On Thursday, Nov. 12, variety had a count. The dinner-specials list included six appetizers and nine dinner choices. Those sheets are written to be replaced. Ladner, speaking about small, shareable plates, told Cleveland.com, "I think diners are getting irritated with it. I think guests are looking for something that's more like we do." Cleveland Scene has set that guest-focused service against diners chasing Michelin stars and tasting-menu marathons.
From Line Cook to a Small Group
The chef making that case took a short path to the job. Ladner is from Texas. He moved to Northeast Ohio because his wife, Alyssa, is from there, after graduating as valedictorian of his class at the Culinary Institute of America. Giovanni's hired him as a line cook in 2010. He was sous chef three months later and chef three months after that. The anniversary coverage dates the chef's title to 2010, six months after he started.
Quagliata and Ladner own and operate Giovanni's, and the Beachwood room is no longer the only door. Tutto Carne is in Cleveland's Little Italy. The Village Butcher and Smokehouse 91 are in Mayfield Village, as is Cuoco Bello. Paloma and Haute Donuts & BBQ are in Shaker Heights' Van Aken District, where Alyssa Ladner manages Paloma. Tableside zabaglione on Chagrin Boulevard and doughnuts in Van Aken belong to the same owners.
Quagliata cooks at The Village Butcher by day and works Giovanni's in the evening. The night half of that schedule is still 25550 Chagrin Blvd., lunch and dinner, with Gregori at the door for all 50 years and Ladner in the kitchen for 17. The Nov. 12 dinner specials were five days old when the anniversary coverage ran. Specials lists are built to turn over. His evening shift is the part with a 50-year record.









