
A sign inside Freeman's Grub & Pub in Greensboro has turned into a national talking point about tipping, after word spread that the restaurant will add a 20 percent gratuity to a customer's bill once staff notice a pattern of poor tipping without explanation. The notice has been up for months, but it only caught fire online recently, pulling the small business into a much bigger argument about where tipping culture in America is headed.
The policy itself is straightforward, according to the sign quoted by the Daily Mail: “If our employees have two separate instances of you not tipping well without any explanation, we will add a 20 percent auto-gratuity fee on your bill.” The notice also states that the restaurant keeps proof on hand in those situations, reading, “Your receipts will be saved if this is the case.” Freeman's is co-owned by Emily and Kevin Purcell, and reporting from WFMY News 2 indicates the couple introduced the rule after employees raised concerns about regulars who repeatedly failed to tip.
How the Policy Came Together
Per WFMY News 2's reporting, it was an employee who first suggested an automatic gratuity policy as a way to address the problem. Emily Purcell told the station that regulars sometimes tipped poorly or not at all, and she has been clear that the surcharge is not applied across the board — the gratuity does not apply to every customer, she said. The sign had reportedly been hanging at the gastropub for months before anyone outside the restaurant seemed to notice.
That changed once the policy surfaced on Reddit and the backlash rolled in. Owner Kevin Purcell told the Daily Mail he believes most of the one-star reviews that followed came from people who never actually set foot in the restaurant, saying many were “trying to make it seem like they were [at the restaurant] when they weren't.” Emily Purcell echoed that sentiment to WFMY News 2, saying the negative reviews hadn't shifted her view of the policy because, in her telling, the reviewers hadn't visited the business. Social media users, for their part, have criticized the rule as effectively forcing customers to tip.
Owners Say They're Not Backing Down
Kevin Purcell was blunt about where the couple stands now that the policy has gone viral. “We will stand behind our controversial policy and our amazing staff 100 percent,” he told the Daily Mail. Emily and Kevin Purcell have said supporting their employees and their business remains the priority, and Emily has argued that restaurant employees deserve to be paid for their work regardless of their schedule.
There's also a financial upside the Purcells point to. Emily Purcell told WFMY News 2 that a longtime employee had said gratuities increased once the rule became a topic of conversation. Mia Alsup and Sherry Mimis, two regular customers at Freeman's, told the station they hadn't even noticed the sign before it went viral. Alsup said she supports tipping restaurant workers, and Mimis said servers should be compensated for the service they provide.
A Debate That Extends Beyond One Gastropub
Freeman's isn't the only venue experimenting with mandatory gratuities. A separate Daily Mail report described a pool hall called the Corner Pocket in Williamsburg, Virginia, where a receipt showed a $3.40 late-night auto-gratuity tacked onto an order of two $8.50 Guinnesses; that venue's posted policy reads, “Auto gratuity is added to groups of 6+ and after 10pm.” The same report cited a Popmenu survey finding that 78 percent of Americans believe tipping culture has become “ridiculous,” and that nearly half of respondents said they had actively cut back on gratuities in 2026.
There's also a legal wrinkle worth noting. According to a fact sheet from the U.S. Department of Labor, a compulsory service charge is not considered a tip under the Fair Labor Standards Act, and any sums distributed to employees from such charges are likewise not treated as tips. That distinction matters for how restaurants handle payroll and taxes. Freeman's policy is a 20 percent auto-gratuity applied in specified circumstances.
The sign had been up for months before the policy went viral. Between the receipts being saved as backup and tips reportedly climbing since the controversy began, the owners seem to be betting that standing firm is better for business than backing off.









