Indianapolis/ Politics & Govt

Indiana Joins $48.5 Million Settlement Against Landlord Giant Over Rental Fees

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 09, 2026
Indiana Joins $48.5 Million Settlement Against Landlord Giant Over Rental FeesIndiana Attorney General's Office — Announced State Settlement Participation
Google Street View

Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita announced Thursday that the state has joined a $48.5 million nationwide settlement with Progress Residential LLC and its parent company, Pretium Partners LLC, resolving allegations that the corporate landlord advertised rental prices that left out required costs, mishandled security deposits, and failed to properly address tenant complaints and maintenance issues.

Indiana joined the enforcement action alongside the Federal Trade Commission and authorities from Arizona, Colorado and Utah, according to ReadTheReporter. Rokita's office said its consumer protection division and homeowner protection unit helped investigate the companies and develop claims under Indiana consumer protection laws, per the state's announcement reported by WISH-TV. The underlying federal complaint was filed in the Northern District of Georgia.

What Regulators Say Went Wrong

Per the federal complaint, the companies advertised rental prices that excluded the full cost required of tenants and imposed improperly disclosed fees. Regulators also allege the companies mishandled security deposits, misrepresented property conditions, and failed to adequately address maintenance requests, according to the report from ReadTheReporter.

The complaint further alleges that tenants were restricted from sharing reviews and experiences about their rental properties. The settlement provides $48.5 million in monetary relief for consumers nationwide, with those funds to be distributed as directed by the court's order, the same source reports.

Conflicting Figures on the Full Settlement Total

Reported figures for the overall settlement vary. A Federal Trade Commission press release snippet describes a proposed payment of $49.75 million — $48.5 million of which would go to the FTC for consumer redress, plus an additional $1.25 million, according to the Federal Trade Commission. HousingWire, meanwhile, reports that Progress and Pretium agreed to pay $49.8 million total, while separately confirming that consumer redress funds total $48.5 million, according to HousingWire.

New Rules for Disclosures and Deposits

Beyond the monetary relief, the settlement requires the companies to change their rental-price advertising, security-deposit handling and responses to tenant complaints, WISH-TV reports. Going forward, the companies must disclose total monthly rental costs in advertisements and identify mandatory fees before tenants agree to rent a property.

On deposits, the companies must provide itemized explanations for security deposit deductions and maintain documentation supporting those deductions. They must also stop charging tenants for ordinary wear and tear. The settlement additionally requires improvements to maintenance and customer service practices, and it prohibits enforcement of contractual terms that unlawfully restrict tenant reviews. Renters must also be given a way to dispute fees without losing the ability to pay rent.

Part of a Broader Pattern for Corporate Landlords

This is not the first major settlement involving a large single-family rental operator. In 2024, Invitation Homes, described by HousingWire as the largest owner of U.S. single-family rental homes, agreed to pay $48 million to consumers and change some of its practices — a case that drew comparisons as regulators continue scrutinizing how big institutional landlords price and manage rentals.

The complaint and settlement order are available through the Indiana Attorney General's office, according to WISH-TV's report. It remains unclear how or when individual Indiana tenants might access the nationwide relief funds, as neither the state announcement nor the federal filings reviewed so far spell out a claims process or eligibility details.