
An Indianapolis man was sentenced to 18 years in the Indiana Department of Correction this week after admitting he sold the fentanyl that killed 's Philip Mulinaro in December 2024. Shane Johns pleaded guilty on Nov. 16 to reckless homicide and dealing in a narcotic drug, closing out a case that began when Mulinaro was found dead inside his truck in the 700 block of East Thompson Road.
According to WTHR, prosecutors dismissed three other charges, dealing in a controlled substance, dealing in a narcotic drug, and obstruction of justice, as part of the plea deal, according to online court records. An autopsy detected both fentanyl and methamphetamine in Mulinaro's system and determined that he died from a drug overdose, a finding also reported by FOX59, which noted that investigators said Johns sold Mulinaro the fatal dose of fentanyl on Dec. 20, 2024, the day before he was found.
Surveillance Footage and a Missing Phone
Court documents described how surveillance footage showed Mulinaro approach a car around 3:30 p.m. on Dec. 20, 2024, then return to his truck. The truck remained in the parking lot overnight until officers found his body the following morning. Police searching Mulinaro's car for his cellphone came up empty, according to court documents, even though his sister told police that Mulinaro always kept his phone in his possession.
Security camera footage appeared to show a man searching Mulinaro's car and attempting to retrieve something from inside it. Investigators believed the man took the phone specifically to hide messages that could lead police back to the drug supply. That detail, along with the surveillance video of the hand-to-hand transaction, helped detectives identify Johns as a suspect in the case. FOX59's reporting on the charging documents noted that multiple witnesses also alleged that Johns had dealt the victim the fatal dose.
Arrest Followed a Short Pursuit
Johns was arrested for Mulinaro's overdose death in March 2025, months after investigators said IMPD's Overdose Death Task Force and DEA agents worked together to build the case against him. Detectives found Johns getting into a car on Feb. 5, 2025, in the 4400 block of Southport Crossing Drive, near East Southport Road and Interstate 65. He led police on a short pursuit after failing to stop for officers before he was arrested.
Inside Johns' car, police reported finding approximately 77 grams of fentanyl, around $30,000 in cash, a loaded handgun, and other evidence of narcotics dealing. Those findings, laid out in court records cited by WTHR, formed the basis for the additional drug charges that prosecutors later dropped as part of his plea agreement.
A Broader Pattern Across Indiana
The case echoes a similar prosecution in Bloomington, where Shaquan Hosea pleaded guilty to supplying a lethal dose of fentanyl to two sisters who died a day apart, receiving 12 years for drug-induced homicide, according to WGLT. Fentanyl-related prosecutions have become a recurring feature of Indiana's response to a drug crisis that has strained Marion County in particular, where 506 people died from suspected drug overdoses in 2024, according to reporting from The Indianapolis Star.
Mulinaro's death adds to a toll that local health officials have tracked closely. A Marion County overdose fatality review found that fentanyl or a fentanyl analog turned up in 13 of the toxicology tests reviewed, or 93 percent, underscoring how dominant the drug has become in overdose deaths across the county.









