Salt Lake City/ Food & Drinks

Logan's Charlie's Ice Cream Scoops Its Last Shake After 36 Years

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
Logan's Charlie's Ice Cream Scoops Its Last Shake After 36 YearsSource: Google Street View

Charlie's Supreme Malts and Ice Cream on Main Street in Logan will serve its final scoops Saturday, Nov. 21, closing for good after more than 36 years as a hometown fixture. Founder Craig Charles Earl, now 74, says he's simply ready to retire, and in the weeks leading up to the closure the shop has been packed with regulars making one last trip for a shake.

Earl's path into the ice cream business started almost by accident. According to The Salt Lake Tribune, he owned a Logan factory that produced goods for Creamies Premium Ice Cream back in 1986, and when space opened up at the front of that building, he launched the Premium Malt Shoppe inside it. That first year, the shop merely broke even, but it soon grew into a success in its own right.

Earl’s manufacturing roots were part of a longer Cache Valley frozen-treat tradition. Creamies’ company history says a local grade-school principal approached an ice cream company in the late 1950s seeking a more nutritious frozen treat made with milk instead of sugar water. That request led to Creamies’ original chocolate, orange and banana bars, linking Earl’s later factory operation to a regional ice-cream business that was already established decades before his malt shop opened.

From Malt Shoppe to a Logan Institution

By 1990, Earl was ready to strike out on his own, opening what locals simply call Charlie's Ice Cream. The Tribune reports he worked with former Utah State University professor Carl Anthon Ernstrom to perfect the shop's signature ice cream mix, a formula Earl has described as the business's secret sauce.

That mix became the heart of the shop's identity. “A higher-quality, higher-fat mix, and that's our biggest seller,” Earl said, per the same account, pointing to the milkshakes made from it as the top item on the menu for decades.

A Family Decision to Finally Close

Earl isn't selling the business to a new owner; he's choosing to close it outright. The decision comes roughly five years after he first considered shutting the doors, only to be talked out of it by his wife, Lorraine Earl, and daughter, Angie Harper, who urged him to keep going and who have run the shop during its final years, the Tribune notes.

This time, at 74, Earl said he's ready to retire for good, bringing a 36-and-a-half-year run to a close this weekend.

Generations of First Dates and Family Trips

For many longtime customers, the closure marks the end of a place tangled up in their own personal histories. Bruce and Vicky Gates had their first date in the shop's corner booth about 14 years ago and still return for chocolate chip cookie dough milkshakes, according to the Tribune's reporting. Vicky Gates said young couples on first dates there are cute, usually college students working up the nerve to talk over ice cream.

Gabriel Gonzalez's connection to Charlie's goes back even further. He first walked through the doors with his family at age 7, and he's now 32, part of the wave of longtime patrons who have shown up in force as the Nov. 21 closing date approached.

When the lights go off Saturday night, Logan will lose a shop that spanned generations of first dates, family outings, and milkshake runs. For Earl and his family, it closes a chapter that began with a vacant storefront in a Creamies factory and grew into one of Main Street's most recognizable names.

Charlie's closure comes as downtown Logan is also organizing around business vitality and preservation. The Logan Downtown Alliance has worked for more than 20 years to support downtown businesses, including through events such as the Sidewalk Sale and Main Street Local Market. In May 2026, the Alliance became Utah’s first organization to receive both state and national Main Street accreditation for preservation-based economic growth—a broader effort to keep the district’s storefronts and public spaces active.