Miami/ Real Estate & Development

Miami Beach Office Tower Tied To CrowdStreet Fraud Nears $58M Sale

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Miami Beach Office Tower Tied To CrowdStreet Fraud Nears $58M SaleLincoln Place — Approximate Site of Pending Leasehold Sale
Google Street View

An eight-story office building at 1601 Washington Avenue in Miami Beach that was once entangled in a federal fraud case is headed toward a sale reported at roughly $58 million, with city commissioners set to decide Wednesday whether to waive the city's Reciprocal Right of First Transaction. The property, known as Lincoln Place, sits on city-owned land in a neighborhood that has steadily morphed into a South Beach office hub.

According to The Real Deal, an entity called AE 1601 Washington is under contract to buy the leasehold interest in the building for $57.8 million. That entity is tied to Abraham B. Schwartz of Alfred Equities and the family trusts of Aryeh May and Rivka May, and the deal would see the buyer purchase the leasehold from Granite Point Mortgage Trust.

The building itself has been measured differently across reports as well. The Real Deal's coverage lists Lincoln Place at 106,700 square feet of offices, 28,500 square feet of retail, a 493-space garage and a 1.5-acre site, while Commercial Observer's account cites 106,652 square feet of office space, 28,483 square feet of ground-floor retail, the same 493-space garage, but a 1.4-acre site. Earlier in 2025, the same Real Deal report had pegged the building at 111,400 square feet of offices and 26,700 square feet of retail on a 499-space garage, underscoring how much the numbers have shifted across coverage of the property.

City Holds a Right of First Refusal

Because Miami Beach owns the land underneath Lincoln Place, the city holds a Reciprocal Right of First Transaction on any sale of the leasehold, and under the ground lease's terms the city has 45 days to decide in writing whether to exercise its right of first offer, according to a City of Miami Beach agenda attachment. Commissioners are expected to vote Wednesday on whether to waive that right, clearing the way for the sale to proceed, though the outcome of that vote has not yet been determined.

Nearly 91,000 square feet of space at Lincoln Place is available, per the Real Deal's reporting, and a 2025 listing report found the building just 14.8 percent leased, with all of its retail space sitting empty. Granite Point Mortgage Trust acquired the leasehold early in 2025 through a lease-in-lieu-of-foreclosure arrangement with Nightingale Properties, after Nightingale owed Granite Point $84.7 million in principal, interest and other costs, records cited by the outlet show.

A Building Tangled in a Federal Fraud Case

Nightingale Properties was led by Elie Schwartz, who pleaded guilty to wire fraud that prosecutors alleged misappropriated roughly $62.8 million from about 800 investors through the CrowdStreet platform. The U.S. Department of Justice says Schwartz was sentenced to 87 months in prison, followed by three years of supervised release, and ordered to pay restitution of $45,079,485.03. Most of the misappropriated funds were intended for the purchase of an Atlanta office complex, while some were earmarked for Lincoln Place itself, and Schwartz was supposed to repay investors from the eventual sale of the building.

Schwartz had previously put Lincoln Place under a for-sale contract in 2023, agreeing to sell it to Robert Rivani and Mathieu Massa's Massa Investment Group for about $82 million, but that deal fell through and the sale never proceeded. The building's long path from a collapsed $82 million contract to a far lower figure years later reflects just how much its fortunes have shifted since the fraud case became public.

South Beach's Office Market Keeps Shifting

The stretch of South Beach around Lincoln Place has developed into a genuine office market, with Commercial Observer noting that a venture led by Pebb Capital paid at least $70 million for the 97,500-square-foot Uno building over the summer, and that Rivani separately bought a neighboring 156,752-square-foot asset for $31.5 million. The Real Deal has also reported that Eighteen Sunset in Sunset Harbour was completed and fully leased, and that developers were building the five-story Fifth Miami Beach office building at 944 Fifth Street and 411 Michigan Avenue. The Fifth Miami Beach, a boutique office building in the South of Fifth neighborhood, was recently completed as well.

Not every proposal nearby has gone smoothly. Miami Beach voters this month rejected Rivani's request to expand his 1691 Michigan Avenue office building onto the top floors of its garage and extend its city-property lease through 2132, a reminder that deals involving city-owned land in Miami Beach face extra layers of public scrutiny.

The broader Miami office market, meanwhile, has been tightening. CBRE reported that vacancy fell by 540 basis points over the past five years through the third quarter of 2026, while average asking rents climbed 55.5 percent over that same period. Quarter over quarter, vacancy decreased by 20 basis points and asking rents rose by 2.2 percent, even as construction underway across the market expanded by 1.4 million square feet in the third quarter alone, according to the same report.

Miami-Real Estate & Development