
An 85-year-old Michigan City man convicted of molesting a young girl over a span of six years and possessing child pornography will serve out his full 96-year sentence after Indiana's Court of Appeals rejected his bid for a lighter term. John Hupertz had asked the court to cut his sentence to 33 years, arguing in part that he had otherwise lived a law-abiding life, but the appellate judges denied that request and upheld his convictions in full.
The decision, reported by The Times, closes out the appellate chapter of a case that began with a LaPorte County jury convicting Hupertz in 2025 on three counts of child molesting and two counts of possessing child pornography. According to court records cited in that report, Hupertz fondled a young girl he believed was asleep at least twice a month over six years, while she was between the ages of 4 and 10. The girl reported the abuse to the Michigan City Police Department when she was 19, court records show.
Investigators later found child sexual abuse material on Hupertz's electronic devices, and he told police he had viewed child pornography on his computer, according to court records. A separate local report from hometownnewsnow.com said more than 7,000 sexual images of children were found on his computers. That outlet also reported Hupertz was sentenced to 96 years in La Porte Superior Court 1; its earlier verdict report said he was 84 when the jury found him guilty, while the more recent appellate coverage lists his age as 85.
Appeals Court Rejects Both Defense Arguments
On appeal, Hupertz raised two central arguments. He contended his trial was flawed because child-molesting offenses were added to the case four years after the original charges were filed, and he separately challenged the jury instructions given at trial. The Court of Appeals rejected both arguments, finding that the trial followed all scheduling and procedural requirements and that any potential errors were outweighed by the evidence that Hupertz committed the charged offenses, per the same account.
In affirming the sentence, the appeals court went further than simply upholding the jury's verdict. The panel stated that Hupertz's conduct greatly exceeded the five counts on which he was convicted at trial and revealed what the court described as a decades-long immersion in perpetrating and viewing child sexual abuse, according to the report from The Times.
What Comes Next
With his earliest possible prison release now set for shortly after his 140th birthday, according to court records, Hupertz's legal options are narrowing. He may still seek review from the Indiana Supreme Court, though the appellate decision stands as the latest word in a case that has moved through LaPorte County and La Porte Superior Court 1 since the original charges were filed.









