
Patrick Koaneil Brown, a 48-year-old Midvale man, is leaving a 2021 Murray killing with 36 months of probation rather than a homicide conviction. A judge found him guilty of possessing a dangerous weapon as a restricted person, a second-degree felony, after a second jury acquitted him of manslaughter and three counts of felony discharge of a firearm.
Third District Judge Adam Mow imposed that sentence on Nov. 5 and suspended the statutory prison term of one to 15 years, KSL reported. He credited Brown with 1,979 days already spent behind bars — more than five years — and ordered a cognitive behavioral course and an anger management course. Defense attorney Rudy Bautista had recommended probation.
A sale, a taunt, then four shots
Darnell Brown, who was not related to Patrick Brown, was shot and killed on April 21, 2021, after a road-rage confrontation in Murray. He was driving with his fiancée and two daughters. Patrick Brown had been selling clothes from his car to a friend of Darnell Brown's.
What followed is drawn from court documents and the appellate record, as reported by KSL. Darnell Brown made fun of Patrick Brown's Range Rover. His fiancée reported that he wanted to fight and got out of his car. Patrick Brown got a gun from his car. Darnell Brown followed for several blocks, yelling and honking. Patrick Brown threatened to shoot if the following continued. Darnell Brown rammed the back of his vehicle.
Patrick Brown then fired four shots out of his window as he passed Darnell Brown. He later reported believing Darnell Brown had a weapon, and he admitted shooting him after being followed and having his car bumped. The second jury did not convict him for that shooting. The gun itself is what remained.
Murder, then manslaughter, then neither
The first jury, in 2022, found Patrick Brown guilty of murder but determined he had acted with imperfect self-defense, KSL reported. That finding produced a manslaughter conviction rather than a murder conviction.
On Sept. 17, a second set of jurors found him not guilty of manslaughter and not guilty of three felony counts of discharging a firearm. The killing that put him in custody for years is no longer attached to a conviction.
A detective's conclusion undid the first verdict
The path back to a jury ran through the Utah Court of Appeals. Patrick Brown argued that a detective should not have testified that damage to the car was more likely criminal mischief than aggravated assault — a legal conclusion, not a factual observation for the witness to hand the jury.
The appellate court agreed that the inadmissible testimony prejudiced him. In State v. Brown, the judges wrote that they vacate Brown's conviction and remand the matter for a new trial. The second trial erased the homicide and discharge counts. It did not erase the restricted-person charge.
No anger issue, the defendant said
That remaining felony rests on earlier convictions. Patrick Brown was convicted of bank robbery and aggravated assault in an Alabama case, which is what made him a restricted person when he had the gun in Murray.
At sentencing he questioned why he needed the courses after a jury found him not guilty, and he said he does not have an anger issue. Mow's account of the conviction, as reported by KSL, was narrower than the courses might suggest: it was based on Brown choosing to show a firearm in a moment when the judge did not think there was a threat.
The split is now the whole case. Jurors declined to convict him for firing four shots and killing a man who had been driving with his fiancée and two daughters. The judge’s felony conviction was for possessing a dangerous weapon as a restricted person; he suspended a prison term of up to 15 years and sent him to anger management after he said anger was not his problem. What he has left to serve is 36 months of probation, on top of the 1,979 days already counted.









