Salt Lake City/ Crime & Emergencies

Murray School District Admits Staff Illegally Secluded Nonverbal 8-Year-Old Girl

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Murray School District Admits Staff Illegally Secluded Nonverbal 8-Year-Old GirlSource: Google Street View

A Murray City School District investigation has found that staff at Parkside Elementary illegally secluded a nonverbal 8-year-old girl, continuing the isolation even as she experienced physical distress, urinated in her clothing and disrobed. The district also found that employees tipped a wagon onto its side to remove the third grader rather than following approved physical guidance protocols, and that staff failed to properly notify her mother as required by law.

The findings, detailed by FOX 13 News Utah, center on a student diagnosed with autism who is nonverbal. The district determined Parkside did not meet the legal threshold required to place her in seclusion, an emergency intervention that involves involuntary confinement and isolation from peers. Under Utah law, seclusion is permitted only in extreme circumstances when a child poses an immediate and significant safety threat to themselves or others.

Wagon Used Instead of Approved Protocols

Investigators found that Parkside repeatedly used seclusion in response to nonviolent property disruption — including the girl throwing beans, food or a lunch tray, and knocking over desks. That kind of property disruption, the district determined, did not satisfy the legal prerequisite of imminent risk of physical violence or serious bodily harm needed to justify seclusion.

The investigation also found that staff did not continuously observe the girl at times when interior lights were off and window coverings or staff positioning blocked direct visual supervision, and that the school failed to properly document seclusion instances, including one instance reported 10 days after it occurred. Rather than using approved physical guidance protocols to remove her, employees tipped a wagon onto its side, according to the district's findings. Parkside also violated its own policies requiring immediate release when a student shows physical distress or risk of harm, the investigation found, and did not stop seclusion when the girl urinated in her clothing and disrobed.

Mother Noticed Changes Before Learning the Truth

Billie Lopez, the girl's mother, told FOX 13 that her daughter could not tell her about her school day or any trauma she experienced and could not express her feelings because she is nonverbal. Lopez said she noticed her daughter wanted the lights on and the door open at night, and that she was found huddled by her bedroom door in the mornings — behaviors that Lopez said made more sense only after she learned about the seclusion.

Lopez said schools should not be allowed to put children in rooms and shut the door, and she said she hopes legislators will ban seclusion altogether. She told the outlet she hopes sharing her daughter's story will raise awareness among other parents, especially those with nonverbal children, about state seclusion laws. Lopez also said she hopes schools will better comply with existing seclusion policies, though she said the district's investigation cannot undo the damage she feels was done.

District Says It Apologized and Is Auditing Compliance

The district said it initiated an internal investigation immediately after concerns about the seclusion arose, and that it has since apologized to the student and her family. The district said it performed a professional conduct review of the employees involved, took internal personnel action concerning those involved, and implemented corrective action including staff retraining on documenting and reporting seclusion. The district said it is now performing weekly compliance audits and said it prioritizes the safety, dignity and well-being of every student.

Guy Stephens, a national opponent of seclusion with the Alliance Against Seclusion and Restraint, said the findings are concerning and show that new laws alone do not guarantee appropriate use of seclusion. He argued educators need additional training, and said seclusion should be treated as an emergency intervention used only when there is imminent danger of serious harm. Stephens said a better understanding of Utah law among school staff could reduce both restraint and seclusion incidents statewide.

A Pattern Playing Out Across Utah Schools

Utah state law requires schools to notify parents immediately after an emergency safety intervention, and no later than 15 minutes after its use, according to the enrolled text of Utah Senate Bill 170. The same legislation requires schools to document the reason for seclusion, its duration, and any alternative strategies attempted before it is used.

Utah students were subjected to seclusion about 1,300 times during the 2020-2021 school year, according to federal data, with a vast majority of those incidents involving students with disabilities. By the 2023-2024 school year, that number had risen to more than 2,200 incidents statewide. School districts and teachers have said seclusion is used sparingly and only to ensure student and safety, even as the Utah Legislature has added guardrails around its use in recent years and parents, students and advocates have continued to raise concerns about misuse.

Similar cases have surfaced elsewhere in the state. A mother told KSL.com in November 2024 that her 9-year-old daughter was secluded dozens of times over two years at Elk Meadows Academy in the Jordan School District, with school records showing the student was secluded 18 times in first grade and 24 times in second grade, sometimes as many as three times in a single day. The same report cited a Utah State Board of Education figure showing students statewide missed nearly 60,000 class days in 2023 due to exclusionary discipline, including seclusion, with nearly 80% of those cases involving students with disabilities.