
A North Salt Lake mother says her 6-year-old autistic son, Gunner, was secluded twice during kindergarten at Orchard Elementary in ways she believes violated the law, and that staff failed to follow the behavioral plan meant to keep him from escalating in difficult moments. Lori says the incidents left her son traumatized.
Lori told KSL News that Gunner experienced two alleged unlawful kindergarten seclusions, and she believes his behavioral plan was not followed during those episodes. Incident reports described Gunner throwing and tearing classroom items, and hitting, kicking, punching and biting. Davis School District declined an interview about Gunner's case, telling the station that federal student privacy law prevents it from commenting on information identifying an individual student.
Gunner was secluded several months after Utah’s 2025 law banning seclusion for kindergartners took effect. The district said seclusion is permitted only as a last resort, when a student poses an imminent danger of serious physical harm to themselves or others, and that staff are trained to end interventions once that danger passes, or earlier if physical or serious emotional distress appears. The district also said it requires timely parent or guardian notification along with incident documentation and review following any emergency safety intervention, and that those reviews examine compliance, whether staff need support or retraining, and ways to prevent similar interventions going forward.
Behavior Has Worsened Since First Grade, Mother Says
Per Lori, Gunner experienced several additional seclusions after starting first grade, and his behavior has worsened since then. Nate Crippes said rising behavior problems following seclusion indicate the intervention is not working, adding bluntly that “the system is not working.” He called for better oversight of seclusion use in schools, and both he and Lori called for more funding, training and resources for special education across Utah. Lori said she hopes sharing her son's story will prompt people with power to make change.
Statewide Seclusion Numbers Climbing
The Utah State Board of Education, which oversees school seclusion practices statewide, reported 1,565 seclusion incidents in Utah schools during the 2025-26 school year, a 37% increase over the prior year. Krisanne Lewis said the reasons behind the increase are uncertain, noting that heightened scrutiny along with policy and definition changes make the jump's significance difficult to interpret. She said the state hopes to have more accurate data within the next couple of years.
Even as recorded incidents have climbed, Lewis noted that Utah schools have seen a relatively stable number of individual students experiencing seclusion, while the share of students secluded more than once has doubled since 2022. Separate KSL reporting on data gathered from 2020 through 2024 found disruption listed as the primary infraction in 46.7% of seclusion cases statewide, with the catch-all category “other” the third most common reason, cited in 15.8% of cases, as detailed in KSL's investigation. In 2024 alone, the same analysis found more than 110 seclusions involving kindergarteners, with disruption listed in 100 of those cases.
Compliance Letters Describe Dozens of Violations
KSL investigators obtained 15 Utah State Board of Education compliance letters in November 2025 describing dozens of reported violations, including untrained staff, seclusion exceeding the legal 30-minute limit, use without immediate danger present, and a case involving a kindergarten student. Board staff follow up on apparent violations after districts submit their data, and the agency expects corrective action in response.
Other Utah cases outline similar patterns. According to FOX 13, Murray City School District found that Parkside Elementary improperly secluded an 8-year-old nonverbal student with autism, including in response to nonviolent property disruption and when she showed physical distress; the district also found the school failed to properly notify the girl's mother and inadequately documented some incidents, including one not reported for 10 days. KSL's data analysis also found Provo City School District received a state finding for failing to document all seclusions involving a student named Mark Stovall, requiring the district to complete one hour of virtual training, and noted six occasions when staff did not contact Mark's parents within the required time frame.
Records shared by the parents of another student, Kody Breider, indicated he was secluded on several occasions for behaviors that did not rise to the level of imminent physical harm, including running into a hallway, spraying hand sanitizer and refusing to sit at his desk, per FOX 13's reporting on students' experiences in seclusion. Those records also indicated he was once held in “self containment” for more than three hours, well beyond Utah's 30-minute limit. Under the state's administrative rule, a school employee may not place a student in seclusion for more than 30 minutes per occurrence, according to the Utah Office of Administrative Rules.
Debate Over Seclusion Bans Continues
Some special education teachers have opposed a proposed total ban on seclusion during past legislative discussions, though KSL investigators say they have not, after months of seeking them out, found special education teachers willing to discuss the pro-seclusion perspective on camera.









