
A years-long effort to finally do something with North Tonawanda's long-abandoned Lowry Middle School has collapsed, with the building's owners backing out of a deal to hand the property to the county land bank. Instead, 621 Payne LLC — the company that owns the Payne Avenue site — says it will pursue redevelopment on its own, leaving city and county officials watching closely to see whether that actually happens this time.
The Niagara Orleans Regional Land Improvement Corporation, the county's land bank known as NORLIC, had announced in September that it was working to acquire the school and hand it off to developers, according to WKBW. That plan called for converting the school building into several dozen apartments while turning the land once occupied by the former George J. Vetter Stadium into lots for new homes. But 621 Payne LLC, which is run by Kevin Gersh and Sam Savarino, ultimately declined the arrangement, saying it did not work for them financially or practically.
NORLIC Executive Director Andrea Klyczek told the station the owners had a change of heart near the finish line and decided to develop the property themselves. She said government partners had believed they had already agreed on a plan to transfer the site for market-rate housing with a new developer, only for that understanding to unravel. Klyczek also said the land bank's model relies on enabling ownership transfers paired with mortgage enforcement to make sure development actually occurs.
Owners Now Chasing a Previously Approved Senior Housing Plan
With the land bank deal dead, Kevin Savarino said the owners are now assembling a development team to pursue a previously approved project converting the school building into 88 units of senior apartments. That figure echoes but does not match earlier reporting: a 2021 article in The Buffalo News described a Rochester developer's plan to buy the school and convert it into 87 apartments for low-income senior citizens, while a project page from Savarino Companies has referenced 85 senior apartment units for a historic renovation at the 621 Payne Avenue address.
Savarino also said the owners are seeking approval for residential housing on the grass stadium lot where George J. Vetter Stadium once stood, and that he expects those plans to go before the city council soon. Still, he was careful not to commit to a broader schedule. It is too early to predict a timeline for redevelopment, Savarino said, according to the same WKBW report.
A Building That Has Sat Empty for Roughly 15 Years
The school's history stretches back decades. Lowry served as North Tonawanda City Schools' high school and later its middle school until 2004, before the district sold the property to Gersh in 2007, when he briefly operated a school of his own there. In the years since, as WKBW notes, several redevelopment plans have fallen through, and the building has continued to sit empty on Payne Avenue.
That pattern isn't unique to Lowry. In North Tonawanda, developers David Sutton and David Cloy separately applied for assistance from the Niagara County Industrial Development Agency to renovate the former Colonel Payne school at 460 Wheatfield Street, according to the Niagara Gazette. That plan proposed converting the structure into 37 one- and two-bedroom market-rate apartments while preserving the look of the building's facade, underscoring how often the city's old school buildings have become redevelopment puzzles.
Officials Say They're Watching, But Patience Has Limits
North Tonawanda Mayor Austin Tylec said the city is disappointed and apprehensive about the collapsed deal but intends to support the owners' renewed effort for now. He added that the city may take a more aggressive approach over the coming months depending on whether milestones are met, possibly alongside a state agency partner, saying the city — and even possibly a state agency partner — may take a more aggressive approach to make sure something happens on that site.
County Legislator Rich Andres struck a similar note of cautious patience. He said the county is concerned but will work with the owners if their effort proves sincere, while continuing to explore alternatives. Andres added that all levels of government are monitoring the property and remain committed to making something happen there, a sentiment that leaves the fate of the long-vacant school still unresolved as another redevelopment attempt gets underway.









