
An illegal gambling operation accused of running out of two well-known northwest Indiana restaurants is still working through federal court after agents raided the businesses, and the case took another turn this fall when a magistrate recommended releasing one of its alleged leaders on bond. James “Jimmy the Greek” Gerodemos, named by federal prosecutors as a leader of the operation, was recommended for release on a $5 million unsecured bond while his case remains pending — but prosecutors are fighting to keep him in custody.
The case traces back to an April 2026 indictment accusing Gerodemos and Dean Gialamas of running an illegal gambling ring out of Gino's Steakhouse in Merrillville and Paragon in Hobart, according to the Chicago Tribune. Federal prosecutors alleged the operation took bets both online and in person from bettors located across the country, according to FOX 32 Chicago. That same reporting says some bettors were allowed to gamble on credit without putting money down upfront, a setup investigators allege created the debts at the center of the case.
Not Guilty Pleas, Then a Bond Fight
All 22 people named in the case pleaded not guilty to federal charges on November 19, 2026, the Tribune's report notes. The legal fight has since narrowed in part to Gerodemos's detention status. On September 22, a federal magistrate recommended releasing him on the $5 million unsecured bond, but prosecutors indicated they planned to file an appeal by early the following week, meaning any release would be delayed by at least several days.
Central to the magistrate's recommendation was a legal question about how to classify Gerodemos's alleged conduct. Magistrate Andrew Rodovich ruled that the actions attributed to Gerodemos did not meet the legal standard for a “crime of violence” that prosecutors needed to justify continued detention, per the same Tribune account. The outcome of the prosecutors' planned appeal, and whether Gerodemos has since been released, isn't established in available reporting.
How the Alleged Operation Took Shape
The case became public in dramatic fashion back in April, when federal prosecutors announced a 28-count indictment against 22 people tied to the alleged scheme. Roughly 150 police officers and agents took part in the raids connected to the case on April 29, according to the Tribune's earlier coverage. That indictment alleged the operation ran out of the two restaurants with activity dating back to January 2021, and named Gerodemos, of Schererville, and Gialamas — known as “Dean Gem,” of Naperville — as the organization's leaders.
Federal authorities alleged the group threatened victims and their relatives with violence when gambling debts went unpaid, the Tribune reported at the time. The Indiana Gaming Commission said its own investigation had begun two years before the indictment, focused on bookmaking, extortion, and money laundering tied to the alleged ring.
A Larger Pattern Beyond One Case
Illegal gambling cases like this one are unfolding against a backdrop of a growing underground betting market even as legal sportsbooks have expanded nationwide. The American Gaming Association estimates Americans wager a total of $673.6 billion annually with illegal and unregulated gambling operators, and that illegal operators still account for nearly one-third — 31.9% — of the entire U.S. gaming market, according to the American Gaming Association. The trade group says that market has grown 22% since its last report in 2022.
Not every trend line points the same direction. The AGA's research, conducted by The Innovation Group largely from a survey of 5,284 U.S. adults, found that illegal sportsbooks' market share has actually dropped from 35% to 24% since 2022 as legal options have expanded — though the group notes one in ten sports bettors still wagers exclusively through illegal channels. NBC Chicago's investigative team has also covered the alleged Indiana gambling operation.









