
Dave and Sara LeBlanc of Ogunquit, Maine, have sued the town in federal court, alleging that its enforcement of sign rules against tin rooster sculptures outside their home violated their First Amendment rights. The dispute involves a six-foot-tall rooster the family first placed outside in May 2025 for their daughter Pyper, who is autistic.
The LeBlancs say the rooster helped Pyper feel comfortable while she waited for the school bus and when she returned home, according to WMTW. The family acquired roughly two dozen tin roosters and generally displayed no more than eight at a time, except during the Christmas season, the station reported. They also own The Omelette Factory, a breakfast restaurant attached to their home. The town classified the roosters as signs; the family says they were decorations.
A Letter, Then a Cascade of Fines
On or about April 3, 2026, Ogunquit sent the LeBlancs a letter ordering the removal of all unpermitted signage, including the rooster statues, per the same WMTW account. Days later, on April 6, the town imposed a $150 fine for illegal signage, followed by another $300 ten days after that. The pressure didn't stop there: on June 24, the town added a $500 fine for failing to build a railing the Zoning Board of Appeals had required, and a $750 fine followed on September 17 for not removing or railing the roosters.
That board, in a June 11 ruling, had affirmed the code enforcement officer's determination that the roosters counted as signs — but it also granted a disability variance that would allow two roosters if they were incorporated into a railing attached to the home, the station's report notes. The LeBlancs ultimately paid $1,700 in fines under protest and removed their roosters from public view. The Portland Press Herald offers a different tally, reporting that Ogunquit's code enforcement office had fined the family more than $2,000 since June — a discrepancy the available reporting does not resolve.
Roosters Scattered Across Town in Solidarity
The LeBlancs gave their remaining rooster statues to friends and neighbors, who displayed them outside homes and businesses around Ogunquit in support of Pyper. News reports describe the displays as a show of support for the girl and a broader symbol of neurodiversity awareness and acceptance. One rooster remains in the LeBlancs’ yard, covered while the lawsuit proceeds, according to WGME.
The grassroots support has grown alongside the story's media footprint. A July 2026 report from The Boston Globe put the Roosters of Ogunquit Facebook page at more than 5,000 followers; by the time the Portland Press Herald covered the lawsuit this month, that figure had reportedly climbed to 18,000 supporters.
Family Argues Enforcement Was Selective
The LeBlancs filed their federal lawsuit against Ogunquit on November 16, alleging that enforcement of the sign code violated their First Amendment rights, according to a press release from the Institute for Justice, which represents the family. The suit seeks a declaration that the zoning code is unconstitutionally vague, an injunction barring further enforcement against the roosters, and damages that include repayment of the $1,700 in fines the family paid.
The lawsuit also alleges that Ogunquit selectively enforced its rules. The LeBlancs say other residents and businesses have displayed rooster statues without citations or fines, and point to town records they say show the sign regulations were not applied to decorative displays such as lobster buoys, nautical art, antique farm equipment or large tiki statues. Their attorneys argue those comparisons undermine the town’s rationale for treating the roosters as signs.
What the Rules Say—and a Separate Disability Law
The Ogunquit zoning ordinance document posted by Maine.gov defines an advertising sign as one that identifies goods or services available at a business or provides information about them, including menus posted for public view at restaurants. That definition alone does not establish why the town classified the roosters as signs. The public record described in news coverage shows that the Zoning Board of Appeals granted a disability variance allowing two roosters if they were incorporated into a railing attached to the home. A separate federal legal framework may also be relevant, but it is distinct from the First Amendment sign-code claim. A 2004 joint statement from the U.S. Department of Justice and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development says courts have applied the Fair Housing Act’s reasonable-accommodation requirements to state and local governments, most often in exclusionary zoning or other land-use decisions. That general guidance does not establish that the framework applies to the LeBlancs’ circumstances or claims.
Institute for Justice attorney Daniel Woislaw, who represents the LeBlancs, said the town’s enforcement was not neutral, even-handed or fair, calling it arbitrary. “Towns do not have a monopoly on deciding what art is or means,” Woislaw said. The organization also cited a recent federal injunction protecting a student-painted donut mural in Conway, New Hampshire, as a comparable dispute over displayed art.
Family Says They Had No Choice
Dave LeBlanc said the situation reached a point where the family felt they had no choice but to sue. Sara LeBlanc said Pyper now wonders why the town cannot simply be nice. Ogunquit officials did not provide a comment on the lawsuit, according to the same WMTW report, and have not addressed it in any other cited coverage, including KCTV's account of the dispute.
The case may ultimately hinge on how courts apply the U.S. Supreme Court's 2015 ruling in Reed v. Town of Gilbert, which held that content-based speech restrictions are presumptively unconstitutional and can only survive if the government proves they are narrowly tailored to a compelling interest. Per the opinion, reproduced by the Cornell Legal Information Institute, governments may still regulate sign characteristics like size, materials, lighting, and portability through content-neutral rules — though the available evidence does not indicate how that standard might apply to Ogunquit's handling of the rooster statues. The lawsuit's procedural status and Ogunquit's response, if any, remain unclear for now.









