El Paso/ Weather & Environment

Project Jupiter Critics Repost Report After Developer's Attorney Threatens Legal Action

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
Project Jupiter Critics Repost Report After Developer's Attorney Threatens Legal ActionEl Paso City Hall Plaza — Weather Coverage Landmark
Google Street View

A detailed report scrutinizing the massive Project Jupiter data center near Santa Teresa is back online, weeks after the group behind it pulled the document down under legal pressure. The New Mexico Environmental Law Center and the Tech Initiative restored the report on Tuesday, saying they still stand behind every conclusion in it despite a cease-and-desist letter from the project developers' attorney.

The organizations first published the comprehensive report on Sept. 24 but removed it less than 24 hours later after receiving the letter, according to KRWG Public Media. The attorney, Jennifer Bradfute, claimed the report contained inaccuracies, and after reviewing her letter, the Environmental Law Center said it would stand firmly behind the report's accuracy and conclusions. Bradfute has said she reserves the right to pursue legal remedies against The New Mexican for republishing the report.

What the Report Alleges

The report, prepared for the Environmental Law Center and the Tech Initiative, digs into Project Jupiter's origins, its potential environmental impacts, nondisclosure agreements signed by numerous public officials, lobbying and possible conflicts of interest, and delayed regulatory proceedings tied to a gas pipeline and the project's air-quality permit, according to the New Mexico Environmental Law Center. The project traces back to a memorandum of understanding Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham signed in February 2025 with BorderPlex Digital Assets, a newly established, Texas-based tech company, per the KRWG report. The report describes BorderPlex as secretive, inexperienced and politically connected.

Bradfute, who has lobbied for BorderPlex Digital Assets, disputed claims that she pressured the state environment department to sidestep legal procedures, and said scheduling requests for public hearings were made in writing to meet a New Mexico Air Quality Control Act deadline. She said she told the Environmental Law Center in writing in September that statements about her and her firm were false or erroneous, and said her work with a separate AI company, Apaluma, ended in September 2025.

Money, Water and a Looming Deadline

The financial stakes are enormous. Bradfute said her client would lose $325 million a month if the air-quality permit wasn't issued by November. The Doña Ana County Commission approved more than $165 billion in industrial revenue bonds for the hyperscale data center in September 2025, though the Environmental Law Center describes the same county approvals as more than $165 billion in tax incentives and public financial support — two characterizations of the same county action that the available record does not reconcile.

Water use has been a central flashpoint. The developers originally proposed two natural-gas turbine microgrids that would have used about 1 million gallons of water daily, according to earlier New Mexican reporting cited by the report, before shifting to fuel-cell power instead of gas turbines. An Oracle spokesperson said the project's cooling and fuel-cell systems now rely on closed-loop cooling with an initial fill and limited ongoing maintenance, and the company estimated average annual operational water use, including those initial fills, at roughly the equivalent of nine U.S. households. Oracle also said public drinking water would be used only for everyday workplace needs, and that it launched an initiative intended to save more water in New Mexico than the project uses.

Permitting Delays and Court Fights

Project Jupiter is already under construction at its Santa Teresa site, even as it faces contested water rights, a legal challenge to its air-quality permit and a delayed natural-gas pipeline. The developers separately obtained private water rights from Santa Teresa Capital LLC, and the report notes that New Mexico must reduce groundwater pumping in the region under a Rio Grande Compact lawsuit settlement. The New Mexico Supreme Court temporarily paused the air-quality permitting process on Aug. 23 after environmental advocates alleged a lack of due process, then lifted that stay less than a month later, according to an earlier KRWG report.

A weeklong public hearing on the permit, previously postponed from September, was rescheduled to begin Dec. 7, a delay that rendered moot a previously set Nov. 23 permit-decision deadline, the same KRWG report noted. The state Environment Department has said pollutant concentrations doubled in updated modeling compared with earlier figures the developers submitted. Separately, a New Mexico Department of Justice release said the state Office of the State Engineer had failed for nearly ten months to schedule a hearing on a protest filed Jan. 9, 2026, while a totalizing meter showed a well had pumped more than 100 million gallons of groundwater from the Lower Rio Grande Basin, according to the New Mexico Department of Justice.

Lawsuits Over County Approvals

The Environmental Law Center, describing itself as a nonprofit environmental justice law firm, says it has filed two lawsuits challenging Doña Ana County's handling of the project. The first, filed Oct. 17, 2025, alleges the county adopted its approving ordinances based on an incomplete application and in violation of state and local law. The second, filed Feb. 6, 2026, alleges the county violated the New Mexico Open Meetings Act. The organization says both cases remain ongoing and both seek to void the ordinances that provide Project Jupiter with billions of dollars in tax incentives. A Doña Ana County spokesperson declined to comment, citing pending litigation.

Maslyn Locke, a senior staff attorney at the Environmental Law Center, said the report described corruption, confusion and officials' efforts to ensure the development succeeded. She said Project Jupiter's development would benefit few at the expense of many, but that community opposition works — and the organization has said it hopes the pushback in southern New Mexico can serve as an example for data-center opponents nationwide. Oracle, for its part, said the report was commissioned by organizations litigating against Project Jupiter and simply repeated their allegations, and said the air permit is being reviewed in a public proceeding where every party can be heard.