Miami/ Crime & Emergencies

Six Accused in Little Haiti Gang Killing of Andre Mitchell, 24, Head to Trial

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 19, 2026
Six Accused in Little Haiti Gang Killing of Andre Mitchell, 24, Head to TrialSource: Wesley Tingey / Unsplash

Six men accused of ambushing and killing 24-year-old Andre Mitchell in a Little Haiti shootout more than two years ago are finally headed to trial, with the first group set to face a jury starting Nov. 30. Symarri Williams, Michael Higgs and Sheldred Johnson will go first, while Keon Ponton, Jamauri Glover and Manuel Rivera could stand trial in January. All six have been held without bond since their arrests.

The case stems from a shooting on July 1, 2024, when police responded to a ShotSpotter alert indicating more than 30 rounds of gunfire near Northwest Second Avenue and 52nd Street in Little Haiti, according to the Miami Herald. Officers found Mitchell lying in a swale beside a blue Nissan Altima. He was rushed to Jackson Memorial Hospital's Ryder Trauma Center but died hours later, while a second shooting victim survived. A third person was also wounded in the gunfire, according to the newspaper's report.

Mitchell’s killing was one of two separate homicides in Miami’s North District on July 1, 2024; the other victim was 21-year-old Treysawn Wright. The Miami Police Department’s annual report says investigators recovered 119 shell casings from the two scenes combined, served 72 warrants and recovered 32 firearms during the investigations. Those figures cover both cases, not just the shooting in which Mitchell was killed.

Figures on just how much gunfire erupted that evening vary depending on the source. The Herald's reporting points to the ShotSpotter alert's count of more than 30 rounds, while a separate report from wflanews.iheart.com states that police said over 100 rounds were fired, with one suspect allegedly emptying the magazine of a weapon modified to function as a machine gun. The two accounts have not been reconciled.

Investigators Trace a Rented Kia and a Burned Hyundai

Detectives allege the six men were affiliated with a group called Slice and targeted Mitchell and the others because they belonged to a rival group called Boss Life, the Herald's report states. Investigators believe Mitchell was killed in retaliation for the May 28, 2024, death of 19-year-old Amari Bradshaw, who was killed near Northwest 55th Terrace and 25th Avenue in Brownsville, according to court documents cited by the paper.

Investigators said the men met beforehand at a home in Miami Gardens and surveilled Mitchell and the Altima's occupants for roughly half an hour before opening fire. Court records state that surveillance cameras captured a Kia's license plate near Interstate 95 about five minutes after the murder. That Kia had been rented to a man living at the Miami Gardens address where the group gathered, though the renter has not been charged in connection with Mitchell's killing. Investigators say they confirmed the impounded Kia was at the murder scene using its location data, and surveillance footage reportedly showed Higgs, Johnson and another man inside the vehicle.

Separately, investigators located a Hyundai that had been set ablaze on July 31, 2024. Cell site location data, per court records, placed Higgs, Johnson, Ponton, Glover and other men believed to be in the vehicles at the scene of the murder.

A Glock, an Auto-Sear, and an Arrest in Broward

Williams, 21, was arrested on July 18, 2024, in Broward County while allegedly in possession of a firearm detectives say matched shell casings recovered from Mitchell's murder scene. Williams had reportedly been seen holding a Glock fitted with an extended magazine and a rose gold auto-sear — a device investigators say turns the semi-automatic firearm into a machine gun, according to the Herald's reporting.

An auto-sear can carry legal significance apart from the firearm it modifies: the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives describes a qualifying auto-sear as a machine gun under federal law, subject to registration. Florida law separately makes possession of an operable machine gun a second-degree felony. Those laws provide broader context for the device detectives say they saw on the Glock; the allegations in this case remain for a jury to decide.

Investigators also claim Glover confessed to a witness that he and the Kia's renter killed Mitchell in retaliation for Bradshaw's murder, per the same account. Prosecutors have indicated they intend to describe the six men in court not as a gang but as a “group of friends,” a framing the newspaper's report says will shape how the case is presented to jurors.

The alleged retaliation also sits within a broader local effort aimed at interrupting cycles of group-related shootings. Miami-Dade County’s Group Violence Intervention program, adopted in 2019, is designed to reduce gun homicides involving groups and prevent retaliation, while also offering services such as mental-health and substance-use support. The county describes the initiative as part of a national model; its existence does not establish that the defendants or the alleged groups in this case participated in it.

Split Trials and Self-Incrimination Claims

Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge Marisa Tinkler Mendez decided to split the case into two separate trials. Williams, Higgs and Johnson are scheduled to face the first jury beginning Nov. 30, while Ponton, Glover and Rivera could go to trial in January. All six face charges of second-degree murder, attempted murder and conspiracy to commit first-degree murder. Ponton faces additional charges of tampering with evidence, second-degree arson and possession of a firearm by a convicted felon.

Ponton, Glover and Rivera each said in court, after being sworn in, that they would invoke their constitutional right against self-incrimination if prosecutors sought to call them as witnesses against their co-defendants. The next hearing in the case is scheduled for Tuesday, Nov. 24, 2026, according to the Herald's report.

The defendants range in age from 19 to 25: Higgs is 19, Williams and Johnson are each 21, Ponton is 22, Rivera is 23, and Glover is 25. Mitchell, the man killed in the shooting, was 24.

Miami-Crime & Emergencies