Indianapolis/ Crime & Emergencies

South Bend PS5 Sale Turns Into Armed Robbery, Police Charge 20-Year-Old

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 21, 2026
South Bend PS5 Sale Turns Into Armed Robbery, Police Charge 20-Year-OldMeade St. โ€” Approximate Site of Armed Robbery
Google Street View

A PlayStation 5 sale arranged through Facebook ended with a gun pointed at the buyer on a South Bend side street, according to police, and officers say they tracked down the alleged seller within hours. Cavalier Lewis, 20, is now facing a felony armed robbery charge and is being held at the St. Joseph County Jail.

According to the WNDU report, South Bend police received a robbery report after someone tried to buy a PlayStation 5 that had been listed on Facebook. The buyer and seller had arranged to meet at the Meijer on Portage Road, a common handoff spot for online marketplace deals, on November 18. Police said the seller approached the victim's car at the driver's-side door while holding the gaming console, then claimed he did not have enough gas in his own vehicle to make a trip and asked the victim to drive him to a residence to grab a forgotten power cord.

Police said the victim agreed, but once the pair reached the 1900 block of Meade Street, the seller allegedly pulled out a firearm and demanded cash. The station's report notes that the suspect then left the victim's vehicle and walked to another car that had been waiting for him nearby, leaving the victim to call police.

Real-Time Crime Center Helps Track Down the Vehicle

Investigators with the South Bend Police Department's Major Crimes Unit took over the case, and the department's Real-Time Crime Center helped locate the vehicle the suspect had used to travel to the Meijer parking lot. Officers stopped that vehicle and contacted its driver, identified as 20-year-old Cavalier Lewis. Per the same account, officers recovered a firearm and marijuana from inside the vehicle during the stop.

The St. Joseph County Prosecutor's Office has charged Lewis with armed robbery, a Level 3 felony, on November 20. Under Indiana law, robbery is generally charged as a Level 5 felony, but the Indiana General Assembly's robbery statute raises the charge to a Level 3 felony when the offense is committed while armed with a deadly weapon. Lewis is presumed innocent unless and until he is convicted in a court of law.

๐—ฆ๐—จ๐—ฆ๐—ฃ๐—˜๐—–๐—ง ๐—–๐—›๐—”๐—ฅ๐—š๐—˜๐—— | A suspect has been arrested and charged following a robbery that stemmed from the sale of a gaming console

Police Point Buyers and Sellers to a Monitored Exchange Spot

In its announcement of the arrest, the South Bend Police Department highlighted a resource it offers for exactly this kind of transaction: an Internet Purchase Exchange Location set up at the front of its own building at 701 W. Sample Street. Police described the spot as well-lit and under 24/7 surveillance, and they're advising residents to use it for online purchases and sales going forward.

The case underscores a risk that's become increasingly common as more buyers and sellers turn to Facebook Marketplace and similar apps to swap goods locally โ€” meeting a stranger based only on an online listing, often in a parking lot chosen with little scrutiny. South Bend investigators have not said whether the PlayStation 5, the cash the suspect allegedly demanded, or the power cord were ever recovered.