Bay Area/ San Francisco/ Crime & Emergencies

Two San Francisco Tobacco Distributors Sentenced in $7M Tax Evasion Scheme

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Two San Francisco Tobacco Distributors Sentenced in $7M Tax Evasion SchemeSource: Frank Schulenburg / Wikimedia Commons

Two San Francisco tobacco distributors are headed to prison after being tied to a scheme that cost the state millions of dollars in unpaid taxes, California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced. The case marks another crackdown by state investigators on a corner of the tobacco distribution industry that officials say has repeatedly tried to dodge excise taxes owed to California.

According to a statement from the California Department of Justice, Office of the Attorney General, distributor Ali Tavaf was sentenced to six years in prison, while San Francisco tobacco distributor Ismail Karajah received a sentence of three years and eight months. The case is described in the DOJ's own release as part of what prosecutors call a $7 million tax evasion scheme. Bonta touted the outcome on X, writing on the platform under the handle @agrobbonta that the state had “secured prison sentences against two San Francisco tobacco distributors for a $7 million tax evasion scheme,” and vowing to “continue to hold tax evaders accountable and track down any individuals that put our state funded services at risk.”

How the Case Began

The sentencing traces back to an earlier phase of the investigation, when three owners of a tobacco distribution company were arrested over the alleged scheme. The timing of that arrest announcement is disputed in the state's own records: the DOJ's own release dates it to January 18, 2023, while the California Statewide Law Enforcement Association reports the attorney general made the announcement on January 11, 2023.

Investigators alleged the defendants filed fraudulent tax returns in an effort to evade more than $7 million in taxes, with the CSLEA report putting the specific figure at $7.27 million. The same report states the three suspects allegedly purchased more than $12.7 million in tobacco products from Pennsylvania companies between August 2020 and March 2021, bringing the goods into California without properly accounting for the excise taxes owed.

Charges and the Task Force Behind the Investigation

At the time of the 2023 arrests, the trio faced multiple felony charges, including conspiracy to file false tax returns and money laundering, per the CSLEA account. The investigation that led to those charges was carried out by the TRUE task force, a multi-agency unit that includes the California Department of Justice, the California Franchise Tax Board, the Employment Development Department, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, according to the same report.

A Familiar Name in Tobacco Tax Enforcement

This is not the first time Ali Tavaf's name has surfaced in a California tobacco tax case. A separate, earlier case reported in October 2021 described Tavaf being sentenced to seven years in state prison in connection with an alleged scheme to evade more than $14 million in excise taxes on more than $51 million of imported tobacco, according to the California Statewide Law Enforcement Association. In that 2021 case, Tavaf was ordered to pay $13,508,397 in restitution, on top of $1 million he had already paid to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, the CSLEA reported. It remains unclear whether that earlier case and the current sentencing involve the same underlying conduct, and the two should be treated as separate matters rather than assumed to be connected.

For now, the latest sentences against Tavaf and Karajah stand as the attorney general's newest example of enforcement against tobacco distributors accused of shortchanging the state. As Bonta put it in his statement on X, the office intends to keep pursuing those who put California's tax-funded services at risk.