Oklahoma City/ Politics & Govt

University of Oklahoma Asks Court to Shield It From Suspension Suit

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 18, 2026
University of Oklahoma Asks Court to Shield It From Suspension SuitSource: Michael Barera / Wikimedia Commons

The University of Oklahoma is asking a federal appeals court to end the remaining claims by medical student Megan Hsieh, who was suspended for a year after making two calls to the 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline. The appeal raises whether university administrators can be sued over the suspension or are protected by qualified immunity.

The calls took place in March 2024. The dispute in Hsieh v. Board of Regents for the University of Oklahoma concerns what Hsieh said and how the university responded. Courthouse News Service reported on the appeal, in which university officials assert qualified immunity.

The Speech and the True-Threat Question

Hsieh was a University of Oklahoma medical student when she called 988 twice. The lifeline offers free, confidential support for people in a mental health crisis. In this case, the parties dispute whether her statements amounted to threats and whether the calls were confidential.

Courthouse News reported that Hsieh said she wished a school administrator would die and that she wanted the school to pay. She also said she was tired and done, that she wanted to rip her head off, and that she wanted to end it all at the school.

The counselors escalated the calls, prompting a full threat-response investigation. Daniel Weitman later argued that the evidence showed a true threat. He agreed the calls were for mental-health assistance but disputed that they were confidential.

The Legal Standard and 988’s Limits

In a separate 2023 Colorado criminal case, the U.S. Supreme Court held in Counterman v. Colorado that true-threats cases require proof of some subjective understanding of a statement’s threatening nature, with recklessness sufficient. The ruling does not decide how that standard applies to Hsieh’s university disciplinary case.

The Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration says 988 counselors provide emotional support and crisis de-escalation, with law enforcement or emergency medical intervention used only when necessary, according to its 988 guidance. The Lifeline’s published confidentiality policy allows information to be shared in specified circumstances, including imminent risk of harm or when required by law. Neither policy establishes what happened during Hsieh’s calls or whether an exception applied.

A Campus Locked Down, Then a Year Off

The university responded with security measures, Courthouse News reported: It gave the named administrator a police escort, sent nonessential staff home, limited access to the student union and rescheduled a senior graduation event.

Officials then charged Hsieh with violating the student code based on her 988 statements and suspended her for one year. The university denied her appeal.

Those measures are part of the constitutional dispute. William Winters, appearing remotely, argued that Hsieh made no true threat and that her speech did not disrupt student learning. He said any disruption was not substantial and resulted from the university misinterpreting her statements.

What the District Judge Left Standing

Hsieh sued in October 2025, alleging First Amendment and due-process violations. In March 2026, U.S. District Judge Bernard Jones, a Trump appointee, denied her request for a preliminary injunction and dismissed several claims against the university.

Jones left Hsieh’s First Amendment claims against school administrators in place. Those are the claims officials are challenging on qualified-immunity grounds. The doctrine can end a suit against individual officials unless the right they allegedly violated was clearly established.

Jones's March order did not restore her to school, and it did not wipe out the suspension. It narrowed who could still be sued, and on what theory.

An Unusual Case, in a Denver Courtroom

Courthouse News reported that oral argument took place at the Byron White U.S. Courthouse in downtown Denver before a three-judge panel: Scott Matheson, Veronica Rossman and Timothy Tymkovich. Rossman was appointed by Joe Biden; Tymkovich was appointed by George W. Bush.

Rossman described the case as unusual, noting that Hsieh was a medical student and that the speech occurred off campus during a mental-health-assistance call. Whether the call was confidential remains disputed, as Weitman argued.

Tymkovich questioned whether rescheduling a university event amounted to disruption. The question bears on Winters’s argument that any disruption came from the university’s interpretation of the calls, rather than from Hsieh’s speech.

The 10th Circuit did not indicate when or how it would decide.

November 6, and No Deal

A settlement conference on November 6 did not resolve the case, according to the public docket for Hsieh v. Board of Regents for the University of Oklahoma.

The one-year suspension remains in place. The pending appeal asks whether administrators can be held to answer for disciplining a medical student over statements made on a crisis line, or whether qualified immunity ends the claims before a jury hears them.