
A draft bill in the Utah Legislature would require the state to collect and publish information about who students live with, starting as early as third grade. The proposal, titled Educational Data Amendments, is sponsored by Sen. Lincoln Fillmore, a Republican from South Jordan, and would gather the household data from students taking the English language arts portion of the statewide exam in grades three through 10.
Under the draft bill, students would be asked whom they live with along with other questions about family composition, according to The Salt Lake Tribune. Families would be given the opportunity to opt out, and any data the state eventually publishes would not include identifying information. Fillmore has described the measure as adding just one new piece of demographic data to the state's student reporting.
Fillmore said the point is to see what impact family structure is having in Utah on academic achievement, and he has said the information could help policymakers figure out how to target at-risk funding. The Tribune reports Utah's proposed questions would be modeled after a similar household survey already used by the National Assessment of Educational Progress, known as NAEP.
A National Push Rooted in Project 2025
The Utah proposal doesn't exist in isolation. The Tribune's reporting ties it directly to Project 2025, the conservative policy blueprint that calls for the federal government to collect and publish education data broken out by family structure, including demanding that NAEP make public household data it already collects. Project 2025 argues that family structure is a major influence on student educational achievement and attainment, and it supports policies encouraging marriage, according to the Tribune's reporting.
Project 2025 was led by the Heritage Foundation, which has characterized non-nuclear families as a systemic issue harming millions of children and defines marriage as the committed union of one man and one woman, per the Tribune. Fillmore is separately proposing a concurrent resolution urging the U.S. Department of Education to make NAEP's data public, with a draft resolution stating that the lack of public reporting denies educators, researchers, policymakers, parents and students valuable insight into the factors influencing achievement.
NAEP itself is a congressionally mandated assessment administered every couple of years, mainly to students in fourth and eighth grades, testing subjects including math and reading. Since 2013, NAEP has asked students who lives in their home, a data point now available through its online data tool.
What the Numbers Actually Show
A separate analysis by the Hechinger Report, examining 2024 NAEP results across fourth- and eighth-grade reading and math tests, found a more complicated picture than the family-structure argument might suggest. Among low-income fourth graders in the bottom third by socioeconomic status, those living with both parents scored 199 in reading, compared with 200 for students living with only their mother — essentially no difference. The pattern held across other tests the outlet examined for lower-income students.
The gap widened considerably higher up the income scale, however. Higher-income fourth graders living with both parents scored 238 in reading, 10 points higher than peers living with only their mothers. As socioeconomic status rises, differences by family structure become more pronounced, the Hechinger analysis found, and high-income students raised by a single parent still scored at least 20 points higher than low-income students living with both parents. Among low-income eighth graders, 43 percent lived with only one parent, compared with 13 percent of their higher-income peers.
The outlet also noted a limitation that matters for how Utah's data might eventually be read: the NAEP household survey does not distinguish among divorced families, grandparent-led households or same-sex parents, meaning broad family-structure categories can obscure very different living situations.
Competing Research on Family Structure
Other research cited alongside the Utah proposal paints a starker picture. An American Enterprise Institute report, published in July, determined that students with “intact” families had higher grades than students with other family structures, and researchers there concluded that parental education and family structure were the strongest predictors of U.S. children's grade outcomes after controlling for race, income, residential parents' education, sex and age.
A report from the Institute for Family Studies found that children in non-intact households were 13 percent less likely to receive A's and B's than children in intact, married-parent homes, 47 percent more likely to have their parents contacted about problems at school, and more than twice as likely to be depressed. That same report pointed to 2024 NAEP results showing fourth-grade students scoring below basic in reading now outnumber those scoring at or above proficient, a trend it says began accelerating in 2017, and noted that 12th-grade average percentile scores in reading and math were the lowest since those tests began in 1992 and 2005, respectively.
Separately, Education Week has reported that the 2024 NAEP introduced a new composite measure of student income meant to better capture family and school resources, since schoolwide meal eligibility has weakened the traditional free-and-reduced-lunch proxy for poverty. An AIR study using a similar index found that more of the poorest 20 percent of eighth graders in each state reached basic and proficient math levels between 2003 and 2017, even as 14 states saw widening achievement gaps between high- and low-income students.









