Salt Lake City/ Crime & Emergencies

Utah Rape Data Show Young Adults Hit Hardest, Survivor Says Her Case Was Never Prosecuted

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 12, 2026
Utah Rape Data Show Young Adults Hit Hardest, Survivor Says Her Case Was Never ProsecutedRape Recovery Center — Source of Forensic Exam Data
Google Street View

Federal crime data reviewed in a Utah investigation show that people ages 10 to 19 made up the largest group of rape victims recorded statewide between October 2021 and October 2026, with 4,087 victims in that bracket alone. Close behind were young adults ages 20 to 29, who accounted for 2,589 victims over the same five-year stretch, pointing to a pattern of heightened risk for Utah's youngest residents.

The figures, compiled from FBI data and first reported by KUTV, also recorded 1,698 rape victims ages 30 to 39 and 993 victims ages 40 to 49 across Utah during the same period, according to the station's analysis. The sharp drop-off by age bracket underscores just how disproportionately the youngest Utahns appear in the data, even as the station's reporting does not offer a population-adjusted rate to compare risk across groups.

Hailey Allen Herrod, who was attending Brigham Young University at the time, told KUTV that a man she met on a first date assaulted her when she was 18. She said that after she refused his advances during the date, “he retaliated by drugging, raping, and beating me.” Allen Herrod said the man was never prosecuted, and that the county attorney did not believe he could get a jury to convict.

A Rise in Young Adults Seeking Help

Those numbers track with what the Rape Recovery Center in Salt Lake City is seeing on the ground. The center performed 157 forensic exams for adults ages 18 to 24 in fiscal year 2025, a total that climbed to 181 in fiscal year 2026, the center's figures show. For people ages 25 to 34, the center logged 189 exams in fiscal year 2025 and 204 so far in fiscal year 2026 — though that more recent figure is a year-to-date count rather than a completed annual total.

“We're seeing a rise from year to year,” said Gary Scheller, executive director of the Rape Recovery Center, per the station's reporting. Scheller said young adults can be especially vulnerable because of limited life experience and naivete. The center's mobile response team also received 10 calls over Halloween weekend, mostly from young adults in Salt Lake and Tooele counties seeking help after a rape or sexual assault, the center told KUTV.

A State Senator Says He's Watching the Numbers

KUTV presented its data to Utah State Senator Todd Weiler, who represents District 8 in Davis and Salt Lake counties and serves as Senate parliamentarian. Weiler told the station he was committed to studying the issue. “I'm very committed to studying this issue and seeing what we can do,” he said, according to the outlet's reporting.

The data add fresh context to a long-running conversation about how Utah universities count and respond to sexual assault reports. The University of Utah's federally required campus security report lists 146 reported rapes in 2024 and 175 in 2023, per KUTV's review of the document, while the university itself has stated the 2024 total was 146 cases, compared with 175 in 2023 and 30 in 2022, according to a university statement.

One Relationship Drove Much of the Spike

University officials have said the unusually high totals in 2023 and 2024 were largely driven by repeated reports of abuse within a single relationship. The Salt Lake Tribune reported that 110 of the university's 146 reported rapes in 2024 stemmed from that one multiple-month relationship involving interpersonal violence. Federal Clery Act rules require that each alleged assault be counted separately, even when it involves the same alleged victim reporting repeated abuse within a single relationship, the Tribune noted.

By comparison, Utah Valley University had the second-highest count among Utah schools for rapes reported in 2025, with 12 cases, according to the Tribune's review of campus crime data.

A Pattern With a Long History at BYU

Allen Herrod's account echoes concerns raised a decade earlier about how BYU, in particular, handled reports from survivors. A 2016 Tribune investigation found that of more than 50 people who said they were sexually assaulted while attending the university, a majority said they did not report the assaults. That same investigation interviewed at least a dozen current and former students who said they were investigated or disciplined for Honor Code violations in connection with the sexual abuse committed against them.

The gap between reported assaults and prosecutions is not new to Utah's largest county, either. A 2014 Tribune audit of 270 rape cases in Salt Lake County from 2003 to 2011 found that a mere 6% were prosecuted, with only 16 of those cases resulting in guilty pleas or convictions. Allen Herrod's case, as she described it to KUTV, fits a pattern in which cases involving young victims stall before ever reaching a jury.