Indianapolis

Former Evansville Operations Manager Sentenced to Five Years for $2.5 Million Embezzlement and Tax Fraud

AI Assisted Icon
Published on March 18, 2025
Former Evansville Operations Manager Sentenced to Five Years for $2.5 Million Embezzlement and Tax FraudSource: Google Street View

Marcie Jean Doty, a former Operations Manager based in Evansville, Indiana, has been hit with a five-year prison sentence after pleading guilty to an embezzlement scheme that saw her net over $2.5 million from the company she was employed by. The United States Attorney's Office for the Southern District of Indiana released a statement confirming that Doty admitted to wire fraud, as well as the failure to file and filing false tax returns. Following her prison term, she will face three years of supervised release and must pay back the staggering sum of $2,517,343.05 to her former employer.

Employed by a property management business, according to United States Attorney's Office, Doty executed a range of illicit activities, including unauthorized transfers and check writing. Over the span between May 2017 and June 2022, Doty made away with $1,803,466.38 through these unsanctioned means, comprising 99 unauthorized ACH transfers totaling $503,151.59, and 279 checks written to herself rather than her employer, amounting to $1,300,314.79.

To cover her tracks, Doty manipulated the business accounting software, making it appear as though the money was being used for valid business operations. In reality, the money flowed directly into her personal bank accounts. One especially brazen act involved Doty purchasing a 25% equity stake in the same business she was defrauding, using the stolen funds to make payments toward that purchase.

Adding to her list of financial deceptions, Doty conveniently neglected to include her ill-gotten gains in her tax filings from 2018 through 2020. In total, she failed to report approximately $786,280.70 in income, according to United States Attorney's Office, resulting in the submission of false tax returns. Her approach to cooking the books not only lined her pockets but also defrauded the Internal Revenue Service and by extension, the tax-paying public.

The case against her was the result of collaborative efforts by the FBI and the IRS, pointing to the severity with which the federal government prosecutes financial crimes.