Indianapolis/ Crime & Emergencies

Connersville Man Gets Consecutive 60-Year Terms After Guilty Plea in Two Cemetery-Area Killings

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 20, 2026
Connersville Man Gets Consecutive 60-Year Terms After Guilty Plea in Two Cemetery-Area KillingsConnersville City Cemetery — Across From Durham's Discovery Site
Google Street View

A Connersville man has been sentenced to two consecutive 60-year terms in the Indiana Department of Correction after pleading guilty but mentally ill to murdering two men near separate cemeteries in the city in 2022. Joshua Lee Farmer entered the plea deal on Oct. 7, after just two witnesses had taken the stand in his trial, admitting to killing Thomas Combs and Joshua Durham in attacks that occurred weeks apart.

According to newsexaminer.com, Farmer’s plea came after just two witnesses testified, ending the trial before it reached a jury verdict. Special Prosecutor AJ Bryson told the outlet that the deal moved forward only because both victims’ families accepted it, saying “the plea deal only happened with the blessing and acceptance of the families of both victims.” As part of the agreement, prosecutors also dismissed a separate felony arson case that had been pending against Farmer, according to WTHR.

WTHR reports that Farmer was sentenced to 60 years for each murder charge, with the terms to be served consecutively.

Two Bodies Found Near Connersville Cemeteries

Combs was found dead on Aug. 17, 2022, with multiple gunshot wounds to his head and neck in the roadway at Dale Cemetery in Connersville, as reported by wishtv.com. Investigators found a crushed beer can near the scene, according to a probable-cause affidavit cited in the same coverage.

Weeks later, on Sept. 10, 2022, an officer found Durham lying dead on a sidewalk between two houses, per the wishtv.com report. The location was across the street from Connersville City Cemetery. Investigators said forensic evidence ultimately connected the two killings.

Ballistics and DNA Evidence Tied the Cases Together

Detectives said bullets collected from both Durham and Combs were fired from the same gun, according to fox59.com. A firearm analysis by state police detectives in December 2023 further connected .41-caliber bullet fragments and casings found during autopsies to similar ammunition recovered during a previous search of Farmer’s home, according to the same wishtv.com report. DNA recovered from the beer can near Combs belonged to Farmer, according to court records cited by wishtv.com.

Police also alleged that Farmer made incriminating statements during an October 2023 interview, including telling investigators, “I didn't kill no one on purpose.” Farmer was formally charged with two counts of murder, though the timing of that charge is described inconsistently across reporting — WTHR places it in February 2024, while wishtv.com reports he was facing charges by early March 2024.

Plea Resolves Case Without Full Trial

Farmer ultimately agreed to plead guilty but mentally ill to both murders rather than face a full trial, closing out a case that had stretched from the discovery of Combs’ body in 2022 through years of forensic analysis. The dismissal of the separate arson case was part of the same negotiated agreement, according to WTHR’s reporting.