Chicago/ Politics & Govt

DuPage Clerk Kaczmarek's Bid for Supreme Court Attorney Denied Twice by Judge

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 14, 2026
DuPage Clerk Kaczmarek's Bid for Supreme Court Attorney Denied Twice by JudgeSource: Teemu008 / Wikimedia Commons

Outgoing DuPage County Clerk Jean Kaczmarek's push to take her years-long legal battle with the county to the Illinois Supreme Court has hit a wall. DuPage County Chief Judge Bonnie Wheaton has denied Kaczmarek's renewed request to have an attorney appointed for the appeal, after already denying an earlier version of the same request in late October.

A Second Denial Follows the First

Wheaton's latest ruling closes off, at least for now, the path Kaczmarek had hoped to take after a unanimous appellate panel sided against her last month. According to the Chicago Tribune, Kaczmarek had asked Wheaton to appoint an attorney to pursue Supreme Court review, but the chief judge turned down that request on October 23. Kaczmarek then came back with a renewed request, which Wheaton also denied.

Wheaton had initially appointed attorney Ken Florey to represent Kaczmarek and capped his fee at $25,000, the Tribune's reporting indicates. When Kaczmarek asked again for representation, Wheaton assumed Florey had already reached that fee limit. Florey, for his part, said he would take no action without a judicial appointment and would not take the case pro bono, per the same account.

What the Appellate Court Decided

The underlying dispute traces back to a lawsuit DuPage County filed in 2024 asking a judge to order Kaczmarek to follow county regulations while paying bills, according to the Tribune's earlier report on the case. DuPage County Judge Bryan Chapman subsequently ruled that the clerk's office must follow county accounting procedures and complete budget transfers. The Third District Appellate Court then issued a unanimous ruling upholding Chapman's rulings, a decision the Tribune described as a 3-0 win for the county.

Kaczmarek had said she intended to challenge that appellate ruling, and the Tribune reported she had 35 days from the appellate court's order to file a petition for leave to appeal to the state's high court. As first reported by the Daily Herald, her request for an attorney to carry that fight forward has now been denied.

A Successor Who Says She's Done With It

Wheaton wrote that Kaczmarek had filed the initial appeal as county clerk and that Florey could continue representing her pro bono until Kaczmarek's successor decides whether to continue the litigation, the Tribune's reporting states. Kaczmarek remains in office until December 1, when Clerk-elect Paula Deacon Garcia takes over. Garcia has said she does not intend to pursue the matter further, according to the same report.

Kaczmarek declined to comment on the latest denial, per the Tribune. The years of litigation have not come cheap for taxpayers: DuPage County has spent more than $300,000 on attorney fees tied to the dispute, the paper's October reporting noted, a figure that underscores how much is riding on whether anyone picks the fight back up once Kaczmarek leaves office.