Indianapolis/ Crime & Emergencies

Fishers Fire Code Overhaul Would Slap Scofflaw Properties With $250-a-Day Fines

AI Assisted Icon
Published on November 17, 2026
Fishers Fire Code Overhaul Would Slap Scofflaw Properties With $250-a-Day FinesSource: Zeb Martin / Wikimedia Commons

Fishers properties that ignore fire-code violations could soon face fines of up to $250 a day under a sweeping rewrite of the city's fire-prevention rules. Fire Marshal Tom Payne pitched the plan to the Fishers City Council on Monday night, telling members that current rules leave his office with no real way to force stubborn property owners into compliance.

The proposal was only on first reading, and Mayor Scott Fadness asked the council not to suspend the rules and pass it immediately, saying changes are still needed before a final version comes back for a vote, according to LarryInFishers. The ordinance would repeal and replace Chapter 92 of the city code, the chapter covering fire prevention, and tack on an entirely new schedule of fines. As Payne put it to the council, the city's existing fire-prevention ordinance mainly just stated that Fishers follows the state code — and he described that status quo as, in his words, “honestly, not enough.”

Why the Bureau Says It Has No Leverage

Payne told the council that about 1 to 2% of the schools, churches, apartment complexes, and businesses his office inspects each year fail to correct the violations found during inspections. That may sound small, but with only three staff members in the Fishers Fire Prevention Bureau, those cases eat up outsized amounts of time — the report notes the bureau sometimes has to revisit the same property five, six, or even seven times, time that comes directly out of the schedule for new, first-time inspections.

Under current rules, Payne said, the bureau simply has no way to force those property owners to comply. That gap is the central problem the new ordinance is meant to fix, giving the fire marshal's office actual financial consequences to point to instead of repeated, toothless visits.

How the New Fee and Fine Schedule Would Work

Under the proposal, initial inspections would remain free. Re-inspection fees would start at $100 for the first follow-up visit, climb to $200 for the second, and hit $250 for every visit after that. A violation left uncorrected for 30 days could also trigger fines on its own, and once a property reaches its third re-inspection, the fine would be $250 per day.

Most fines under the plan would double if they go unpaid within 30 days. The ordinance also lists specific per-incident penalties: $250 per day for ignoring a stop-work order, $250 per day for failing to repair a nonworking elevator, $250 per day for failing to establish a required fire watch, $250 for driving over a fire hose, and $250 for submitting a false compliance affidavit. The proposal would additionally set rules governing private fire hydrants, emergency lighting tests, fire department connections, and stairwell signage.

Electrical Hazards and a Warehouse Full of Fireworks

Asked what kinds of problems his inspectors run into most, Payne pointed to electrical issues — extension cords and improper wiring chief among them. He also flagged warehouses storing hazardous and flammable materials as an ongoing concern, citing one warehouse that sells fireworks around the Fourth of July but keeps fireworks stored on site the rest of the year. “They're just storing up a problem,” Payne said.

Payne was careful not to oversell the new rules as a cure-all. He told the council that none of Fishers' recent house fires would have been prevented by the proposed ordinance, including one blaze he said was caused by a faulty battery in a robotic vacuum purchased online. Imminent life-safety threats, he noted, are handled through a separate process — the bureau works with the city's building commissioner to declare dangerously unsafe buildings unfit for occupancy and close them quickly, rather than waiting on the fine schedule.

State Code Sets the Floor, Cities Can Go Further

Payne explained that Indiana's fire code is still the 2012 edition with a handful of 2014 amendments, and that a state effort to update it two years ago faltered — he said no new statewide code is expected anytime soon. Because of that, he said, cities are free to adopt stricter local rules than the state's minimum code allows, calling the state standard the floor rather than the ceiling.

The ordinance would also create a formal appeals process through the Fishers Board of Public Works and Safety for violations of local-only rules, while appeals tied to state code violations would continue to go through state channels. During in-person enforcement, inspectors show owners the exact code section they've violated and answer their questions on the spot.

Council Members Push Back on Education vs. Fines

Some council members pushed for the city to prioritize educating property owners before reaching for fines. Council member Todd Zimmerman echoed that the point of the ordinance is preventing fires rather than generating revenue for the city, and he downplayed the stakes of getting every detail right on the first try. “We're not adopting the constitution here,” Zimmerman said, adding that the ordinance could be revised later if it produces unintended consequences. Payne agreed that education, not punishment, is the underlying goal, telling the council, “that's 100% the intent.”

The ordinance is expected to return to the council for a second reading at a future meeting, giving city officials time to work through the changes Fadness flagged on Monday. Fishers isn't alone in moving toward tougher fire-code enforcement: in Lake County, Crown Point's Common Council has advanced its own amendment that would let that city's Fire Department impose escalating fines — reportedly $100, $250, and up to $500 — on properties that fail to fix fire-code violations, according to CitizenPortal.ai.