
Plymouth officials have laid out exactly what a proposed annexation will cost the city and what it won't, and the bottom line is this: tax rates aren't expected to budge, even though the city's levy is. The city anticipates its levy rising by approximately $41,119, or $34,596 once the circuit breaker is factored in, as it absorbs new territory on its north side.
Breaking Down the Numbers
The fiscal plan, detailed by giant.fm, covers parcels to the north, west, and east of Plymouth's existing corporate limits. The annexation area carries an estimated net assessed valuation of $3,022,346, based on assessed values as of January 1, 2025, for taxes payable in 2026. Looking ahead, the city projects its own net assessed value will climb by $2,539,100 — roughly 0.4011% — once 2027 valuations are in.
That assessed-value bump is expected to generate additional property tax revenue that could help offset the costs of serving the newly annexed area, the report notes. Indiana law requires cities pursuing annexation to develop and adopt a written fiscal plan through a city council resolution, laying out exactly how new territory will be served and paid for.
Where the New Money Would Go
Plymouth's plan earmarks roughly $9,500 a year, plus inflation, for additional police fuel and vehicle maintenance tied to the newly annexed streets. Despite that added patrol territory, the city does not anticipate needing to hire additional officers as a result of the annexation. The levy increase is expected to cover those added police costs directly.
Street-related expenses make up the other major line item: the city anticipates roughly $22,500 per year, plus inflation, in additional costs for supplies, repairs, and maintenance. That same levy bump is expected to cover those street costs too, according to the plan outlined by the report. Capital improvements in the newly annexed area — things like street construction, street lighting, sewer facilities, water facilities, and stormwater drainage — are set to arrive within three years of the annexation's effective date, provided consistent with federal, state, and local laws, procedures, and planning criteria.
Fire Coverage Shifts, Parks Stay Put
Fire protection is one of the more notable service changes baked into the plan. The Plymouth Fire Department currently serves only a portion of the annexation area, while the North Township-LaPaz Fire Protection Territory handles the majority of it today. Once annexation takes effect, the Plymouth department says it will make all non-capital fire services available within the area within one year, at a standard and scope equivalent to what's provided inside the city's existing boundaries.
The department currently fields 16 career firefighters and approximately 24 dedicated volunteer firefighters, serving about 50% of Marshall County's population across just over 100 square miles, providing fire and rescue protection along with advanced life support emergency medical care. The city does not anticipate the annexation driving up fire department costs. Beyond public safety, the city also isn't planning any new parks because of the annexation, and officials don't expect the added territory to create administrative-service demand beyond what current staffing can handle.
Utilities, Trash, and the Fine Print
On the utility side, the city says it doesn't anticipate material additional stormwater and drainage operating costs from the annexation. Monthly trash collection and recycling charges are expected to offset whatever it does cost the city to extend those services into the newly annexed streets. The plan also notes that the annexation area includes municipally tax-exempt agricultural property, which reduces how much assessed value actually gets added to the city's tax base.
Beyond the dollar figures, the fiscal plan is required to estimate effects on tax rates, tax levies, expenditure levels, service levels, and annual debt service payments for four years after the annexation takes effect, and to address how municipal tax revenues and county political subdivisions outside the annexation area — and their taxpayers — might be affected. City officials have been explicit on one point throughout: any percentage increase in the annexation levy won't exceed the percentage increase in the city's overall assessed value, which is part of why no tax rate increase is anticipated even as the levy itself grows.
A Separate, Larger Annexation Fight Looms
Plymouth's fiscal planning work hasn't happened in isolation. The City Council has also been weighing fiscal plans tied to three separate annexation petitions, including a far larger and more contested one covering nearly 900 acres on the city's northeast side, sought for Indiana Tool & Manufacturing and Lilac Holdings, according to a separate giant.fm report. That same council agenda included a much smaller request to annex a home and 3.32 acres at 1221 Elm Street, plus a petition from Graber Commercial Properties to annex a 10-acre parcel at 1655 Pioneer Drive on the northwest side.
The 900-acre proposal has drawn public attention. It pulled 120 residents into a Plan Commission meeting, and at a Nov. 4 public hearing, neighbors pressed officials to clarify who would pay for water and wastewater extensions and to verify the accuracy of floodplain and drainage mapping, per citizenportal.ai. At a subsequent council meeting, 19 individuals spoke on the nearly 900-acre voluntary annexation and rezoning proposal, according to another giant.fm report on the gathering.
The city's levy is expected to increase, but no tax rate hike is anticipated as Plymouth works through its slate of annexation decisions.









